The top reported proficiency rate is 20% in English language arts. The lowest is 11% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Naalehu Elementary School
Naalehu Elementary School sits in the small rural community of Naalehu, near the southern tip of the Big Island, in the Kaʻū District. The town grew up as a sugar plantation settlement under the Hutchinson Sugar Plantation Company and still functions as the main commercial hub for the surrounding district, with shops, galleries, eateries, a bakery, a museum, an old theater, and a hotel strung along the Mamalahoa Highway. Coffee plantations in the nearby Kaʻū coffee district and small local businesses have largely replaced the old sugar economy. The town has seen steady population decline over decades, and the most visible recent civic investment was the expansion of the Naalehu Public Library, which reopened in late 2021. An outdoor market runs twice a week, and the community hosts an annual rodeo and a hula festival. Nearby natural anchors include the Kaʻū Forest Reserve and black sand beaches, including the Green Sand Beach at Mahana.
The school is a regular public school serving prekindergarten through sixth grade and is part of the statewide Hawaii Department of Education. Publicly reported sources describe it as the southernmost school in the United States. Enrollment is moderate for an elementary school serving this grade band. The student body is majority Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, with smaller Hispanic, White, and multiracial groups and a small Asian representation. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals. Data on English-learner status and special-education enrollment was not available in the provided materials, so those population shares cannot be characterized here.
On state assessments, the school's results are low across subjects. In English language arts, the share of students meeting proficiency in the most recent year sits well below what most Hawaii schools post, with the strongest grade still reaching only about a quarter of tested students and the upper grades landing lower. Math results are weaker still, with proficiency declining as students move from third into sixth grade, dropping to a very small fraction of proficient students by the final grade tested. Science, assessed only in fifth grade, shows a similarly low proficiency level. Participation rates on the assessments are generally strong, which means the results reflect nearly all enrolled students rather than a narrow subset. Only a single year of data was available, so no trend over time can be drawn. Average scale scores were not reported. These results do not carry a verdict, but they are the central academic fact a parent would want to understand, and a parent may want to look into this further with the school, asking what instructional supports and improvement plans are in place.
Because the school serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report. No program offerings, course-access data, staffing details, discipline records, or attendance figures were included in the provided materials. The comparison fact-set that would position this school among its county peers was not available, so it is not possible to say here how Naalehu Elementary compares to other Hawaii County schools on these measures. We looked for district-level changes from the Hawaii Department of Education that might affect families but found little of lasting impact, so that section is left out rather than guessed.
The housing market in the school's zip code is more affordable than the statewide benchmark by a wide margin and sits near the national figure, though recent values have declined. Even so, the affordability picture is tight: the estimated mortgage cost relative to local incomes is high, and rent absorbs a large share of household earnings. For families considering a move into the area, housing is attainable compared with much of Hawaii but still demands a meaningful portion of income.
What this school offers is a small, rural, community-embedded elementary pathway in a remote Hawaiian town with deep plantation roots and a predominantly Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander student body. The academic results are a soft spot that a family should examine directly with school leadership. The setting itself is quiet, spread along a highway corridor rather than organized around a walkable grid, with limited new development and a stable-to-declining population. For a family drawn to Kaʻū's rural character and cultural identity, the school is the local option; the academic data suggests it is worth asking focused questions about how the school supports students performing below proficiency before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →