The top reported proficiency rate is 71% in Science. The lowest is 57% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Paia Elementary School
Paia Elementary School sits in a town that has reinvented itself more than once. Paia began as a sugar plantation community clustered around a mill on Baldwin Avenue, drew workers from across the Pacific and Asia, and after the mill closed remade itself as a surf and tourism destination on Maui's north shore. The commercial core along Hana Highway is compact, walkable, and lined with rustic storefronts housing surf shops, galleries, and restaurants. Residential life spreads between Lower Paia near the highway and Upper Paia toward the old mill site, about a mile apart. The town's population has been modest and slightly declining over recent census cycles, with no major new housing developments identified. Historic preservation is active, with dozens of properties surveyed as part of a potential historic district.
The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade and has an enrollment typical for an elementary school on Maui. Its student body is predominantly Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, with a large Hispanic contingent and smaller groups of multiracial, white, and Asian students. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals. The school does not have charter or magnet status; it is a regular public school within the Hawaii Department of Education, the single statewide district. Data on individualized education plans and English learner status was not available, so those profiles could not be characterized here.
State assessment results from the most recent year show a mixed but in some areas strong picture, drawn from very small testing groups. In fourth grade, half of tested students reached proficiency in both math and English language arts. Fifth grade results were stronger: a majority reached proficiency in math, and an even larger share did so in ELA. Fifth grade science proficiency was also high, with most tested students meeting the bar. Third grade proficiency rates were not reported, likely a consequence of the very small number of students tested at that grade level, which can trigger suppression of results. Participation was full or near-full across the tested grades.
Because only a single year of results is available, no trend could be computed. The combined all-grade proficiency summary sits lower than the individual upper-grade results might suggest, reflecting the missing third grade data and the smaller fourth grade figures. Parents reading these numbers should keep in mind that with roughly a dozen students tested per grade, a single student's performance shifts the picture noticeably. Small cohorts make year-to-year comparisons volatile and can explain why some grade-level figures are withheld.
The housing market around Paia is among the most expensive in the country relative to income. The typical home value in the school's zip code sits well above both the state and national benchmarks, and the estimated mortgage payment dwarfs what most local households earn. Rents, where available, consume a large portion of income as well, though renting remains less costly monthly than carrying a mortgage at current rates. This affordability gap shapes who lives in the attendance area and who can move in. Home values have dipped modestly recently, but the price level remains steep.
Beyond academics, several categories parents often ask about were absent from the available data. The locale classification, staffing ratios, attendance rates, discipline reports, course access details, and Title I status were not provided. The district brief for the Hawaii Department of Education did not surface specific policy, curriculum, or budget changes of recent note. A parent wanting a fuller picture of school climate, teacher experience, or special education services would want to ask the school directly, since those pieces did not appear in the records reviewed.
What the data does show is a small, community-rooted elementary school serving a predominantly Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander student body in a town where tourism and surf culture have replaced the plantation economy. Upper grade proficiency results are encouraging, particularly in fifth grade ELA and science, while the smaller third grade numbers leave part of the academic picture blank. The surrounding community is distinctive, tight-knit, and historically rich, but the housing costs put proximity to this school out of reach for many families without existing ties to the area.
See more original research from School Decision →