The top reported proficiency rate is 60% in Math. The lowest is 37% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Mckinley Elementary School
McKinley Elementary School serves kindergarten through sixth grade in Muscatine, a Mississippi River city with a strong industrial and manufacturing base. The school is part of the Muscatine Comm School District and sits in a mixed-use river city that is home to several large employers including HNI Corporation, Kent Corporation, and Bridgestone Bandag, giving the area an economic stability that sets it apart from many similarly sized communities.
The student body is diverse. The largest group is white students, followed by a substantial Hispanic population and smaller shares of Black students and students of two or more races. A majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places the school in a context where economic need is the norm rather than the exception. This matters for families thinking about the peer environment; the school serves a broad cross-section of Muscatine's population.
On the Iowa State Assessment of Student Progress, which the state administers to students in third through sixth grade, McKinley's results present a mixed picture that a parent would want to examine closely. In both math and English language arts, the share of students scoring at or above proficiency falls in a range that is below the district composite and well below the highest-performing schools in Muscatine County. When compared against the other districts in the county, the school's overall proficiency index lands in the bottom quartile. Science results are substantially lower still, with fewer than two out of five students reaching proficiency. These are the school's chief soft spots. A parent moving into the area should ask the school directly about what academic interventions or supports are in place for students who are not meeting benchmarks, and how the school tracks progress toward those goals over time.
The school draws from a housing market where home values are notably below both the state and national benchmarks, making it one of the more affordable areas in Iowa for homebuyers. The typical mortgage payment on a median-priced home here is below the national median rent, which suggests that owning a home in this part of Muscatine is relatively accessible compared to many other communities. Rents, similarly, are modest. The local unemployment rate has been running close to the national average, and median household income in the broader city is slightly above the national figure, reflecting the area's manufacturing and industrial employment base.
The neighborhood around McKinley Elementary is one of Muscatine's hillier residential areas, west of the downtown historic district and the riverfront. The terrain makes walking less straightforward than in flatter parts of the city, and the street pattern follows a radial, ridge-following layout rather than a grid. This is a car-oriented part of town, which is typical for the city outside its walkable downtown core.
No data was available for chronic absenteeism, discipline incidents, or staffing ratios, so a parent cannot see from public records whether there are patterns in attendance or school climate that might be relevant. The school does not serve high school grades, so there is no graduation rate to consider.
For a family weighing this school, the central academic question is straightforward: proficiency rates are below the local and county averages, and the school would benefit from a conversation about how it addresses that. The strength of the school for a given family will depend heavily on the fit between a child's needs and the specific supports McKinley offers, which the test scores alone do not capture. The community around it is an affordable, economically diverse river city with a deep industrial history and a built environment that ranges from historic downtown streets to the quieter, hillier residential neighborhoods where McKinley sits.
See more original research from School Decision →