The top reported proficiency rate is 66% in English language arts. The lowest is 61% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on South Tama County Middle School
South Tama County Middle School, serving fifth through eighth grades, is the upper-elementary and middle-grade hub of the South Tama County Community School District, located in Toledo, Iowa. The school is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and sits within a small county-seat city anchored by the Tama County Courthouse square. A new middle school is under construction on the west side of town on the site of the former Iowa Juvenile Home, with completion expected in 2025.
The student body is fairly evenly split between white students and Hispanic students, with a smaller but notable share of American Indian or Alaska Native students and a modest number of students identifying as two or more races. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school serves roughly four hundred students across grades five through eight, with enrollment distributed fairly evenly by grade. Data on the percentage of students with an individualized education program or those who are English learners was not available in the record.
On the Iowa Statewide Assessment of Student Progress, the school’s proficiency rates fall in the bottom quartile among the districts in Tama County when looking at overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. That said, the comparison set is small—the county contains only two districts—so the bottom-quartile position reflects a narrow field rather than a wide gap. In math, a majority of students scored at or above the proficient level. In English language arts, a larger majority reached proficiency. In science, a majority also met the proficiency bar. Participation rates on the assessments were high, which means the reported results capture nearly the full student population. Because the state testing data covers only a single recent year, there is not enough information to determine whether performance is trending up or down.
Toledo itself is a traditional small-town Iowa community. Its built environment centers on a courthouse square with a historic stoplight and a mix of residential streets, modest downtown commercial activity, and civic anchors like the Wieting Theatre and Toledo Heights park. The South Tama Recreation Trail connects Toledo to the neighboring city of Tama. Healthcare services are available locally, but hospitalization requires travel to Grinnell or Marshalltown. Housing values in the area are well below both the state and national averages, and the typical home is relatively affordable by national standards. The district did not have any recent major changes—such as property-tax shifts, boundary reconfigurations, or curriculum overhauls—that met a lasting parent-relevant impact bar, so no changes are reported here.
For a family considering this school, the picture is clear: the school serves a high-poverty, racially diverse student body in a small Iowa county seat, and its state test results sit lower than the single other district in the county, though a majority of students still reach proficiency in each tested subject. The new middle school building under construction may improve facilities. A parent who values a traditional small-town setting, a manageable school size, and a community with visible civic life will find an honest fit here. A parent focused on higher test scores relative to nearby options will find limited comparative data and may want to ask the school directly about academic support programs, intervention strategies, and how the school serves students who are not yet at the proficient level.
See more original research from School Decision →