The top reported proficiency rate is 22% in English language arts. The lowest is 18% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Garfield Elementary School
Garfield Elementary School sits on Broadway Avenue in Boise, serving prekindergarten through sixth grade as part of the Boise Independent District. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, drawing from the established residential neighborhoods that radiate outward from Boise's downtown core. The surrounding zip code reflects a housing market that sits above the Idaho state benchmark and well above the national one, with home values edging up modestly year over year and rents climbing at a faster clip. For families weighing buying versus renting, the gap between a monthly mortgage payment and monthly rent is wide, making renting the more budget-friendly option in this part of the city by a considerable margin.
The school's enrollment is moderate for an elementary spanning prekindergarten through sixth grade. Its student body is more diverse than many Idaho schools. White students make up a majority, but Black and Hispanic students each represent substantial shares, and a smaller Asian population is present as well. A very large proportion of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which reflects the economic mix of the surrounding neighborhood and positions Garfield as a school serving a broadly working-class community.
On state assessments, the most recent results show proficiency rates that are low across grade levels and subjects. In math, third grade proficiency landed at about a quarter of tested students, while fifth grade was lower still. Several grades had results reported as ranges rather than exact figures, with upper bounds that remained modest, and in some of those grades no students reached proficiency. English language arts followed a similar pattern, with fifth grade showing roughly a fifth of students proficient and other grades reported in ranges with moderate ceilings. Science results for fifth grade were also reported as a range. No participation rate data was available, and average scale scores were missing across the board. The small number of students tested in each grade means that results can swing notably from year to year. A parent looking at these results may want to ask the school directly how it is approaching math and reading instruction and what supports are in place for students performing below grade level.
The Boise Independent District is the largest district in Idaho's capital city. The district brief turned up little in the way of recently reported strategic changes or program shifts, so there is not much to relay on that front. The city itself is a government center, technology hub, and residential community all at once. Publicly reported major employers include Micron Technology, Albertsons, Boise Cascade, J.R. Simplot Company, and IDACORP, alongside state government and Boise State University. The Boise River Greenbelt, an extensive urban trail along the river, connects parks and neighborhoods and is a defining recreational feature. Downtown concentrates cultural institutions like the Boise Art Museum, the Basque Block, and the Idaho State Capitol, while areas farther out become more auto-oriented. The broader Treasure Valley has absorbed sustained in-migration, with technology investment from Micron among the drivers of expansion.
Information on staffing ratios, course access, discipline data, attendance patterns, and specialized programs was not provided, so those dimensions cannot be characterized here. English learner and special education enrollment figures were also missing from the available data. Title I status was not reported either. What the data does convey is a neighborhood elementary school in a growing capital city, serving an economically diverse student population, working through proficiency levels that are currently low. Families considering Garfield will likely want to visit, talk with staff about academic interventions and classroom support, and get a feel for how the school communicates progress to parents. The housing market around it is more expensive than much of Idaho, but renting remains relatively manageable compared with the cost of buying.
See more original research from School Decision →