The top reported proficiency rate is 47% in English language arts. The lowest is 30% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Tiebreaker Elementary School
Tiebreaker Elementary sits on First Street in Idaho Falls, serving pre-kindergarten through sixth grade as part of Bonneville Joint District. It is a regular public school, neither a charter nor a magnet, drawing from a city that publicly reported sources describe as the commercial, cultural, and healthcare hub for Eastern Idaho and parts of Wyoming and Montana.
The school's enrollment is moderate for an elementary spanning pre-K through sixth grade. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, pointing to a community where economic need is common. The student body is predominantly white, with a sizable Hispanic population and small representation from other racial and ethnic groups. Data on individualized education programs and English learner status was not reported, so those portions of the picture remain blank.
On state assessments, Tiebreaker's results paint a mixed picture across grades and subjects. In math, a slim majority of third graders reached proficiency, but that share dropped notably in fourth grade and stayed at a similar level through fifth and sixth. English language arts followed a different pattern. Proficiency in the tested upper grades hovered just under half, with fourth and sixth graders performing similarly. Third and fifth grade ELA results were suppressed in the state data, so a complete grade-by-grade reading is not possible. Science was tested only in fifth grade, where fewer than a third of students met proficiency. Across the board, the school's strongest showing came in third grade math, and the softest area was fifth grade science. A parent evaluating these results may want to ask the school how it supports students in the transition from early to upper elementary grades, where math proficiency dips.
No graduation rate applies here, since Tiebreaker does not serve high school grades. The same goes for AP, dual-credit, and career pathway data, which belong to the secondary level.
Idaho Falls itself is a city shaped by the Idaho National Laboratory, whose research and education campus sits just north of downtown along the Snake River. The lab and its contractors are the region's dominant employer, and the broader economy has added retail, restaurant, and medical sectors since the 1990s. The downtown core runs along the river, with a walk trail, plazas, the Museum of Idaho, the Colonial Theatre, and a public library. The Numbered Streets neighborhood, the city's first planned residential area, sits nearby, and the Snake River Landing development on the west side of the river has added housing, restaurants, and event space. The city has grown steadily over recent decades, and the College of Eastern Idaho's transition to a community college reflects continuing institutional investment in the area.
The housing market around Tiebreaker is more affordable than the state as a whole but sits above the national benchmark. Typical home values in the school's zip code run below the statewide figure, and rents are moderate. With current mortgage rates, renting costs considerably less per month than carrying a mortgage on a typical home, which may influence a family's calculus about buying versus renting in the area.
Information on the district's recent strategic priorities, bond measures, or facility investments was not available in the material reviewed, so that layer of context is missing. The same is true for school-level details on discipline, staffing ratios, attendance, course access, and special programs. No neighbor comparison data was provided either, so Tiebreaker cannot be placed against nearby schools in the county using the available material. What the evidence does show is a standard elementary school in a regional hub city, with proficiency levels that vary across grades and subjects, an economically diverse student body, and a setting where outdoor recreation along the Snake River and proximity to a nationally known research institution shape the community's character.
See more original research from School Decision →