The reported proficiency rate for English language arts is 76%.
Original Research by School Decision on Barbara R Morgan Elementary
Barbara R. Morgan Elementary is a regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in McCall, Idaho, within the McCall-Donnelly Joint School District. It sits on North Samson Trail in a town that functions as both a residential community and a resort destination on the southern shore of Payette Lake, ringed by the Payette National Forest. State Highway 55, the Payette River Scenic Byway, is the single major road connecting McCall to Boise to the south.
The school's English language arts results on the most recent Idaho ISAT stand out as a clear strength. A strong majority of third and fourth graders reached proficiency, and fifth grade results, while a notch below the younger grades, still showed a clear majority of tested students meeting the state bar. Across all three tested grades, literacy performance reads as genuinely solid. This is the kind of consistent reading foundation a parent would want to see in an elementary school.
Math results are harder to read. The state reported proficiency as broad ranges rather than precise figures for each tested grade, which often reflects privacy protections for small subgroups. The third grade range began at a moderate level and extended upward. Fourth and fifth grade ranges were wider, with the fifth grade ceiling landing below where a parent might hope. Without point estimates, it is difficult to characterize math outcomes beyond saying they appear mixed and may warrant a closer conversation with the school, particularly in the upper elementary grades. Fifth grade science was also reported as a range, so a similar caveat applies.
The student body is predominantly white, with a small Hispanic presence and minimal representation from other racial and ethnic groups. The share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price meals is relatively low for a public school, pointing to a more economically advantaged enrollment than many Idaho elementaries. Data on students with individualized education programs and English learners was not reported, and the school's Title I status was not available. No graduation rate applies, as the school serves only elementary grades. Information on program offerings, staffing ratios, discipline, and attendance was also absent from the provided data.
McCall shapes much of the housing picture for families here. Publicly reported accounts describe the town's shift from a lumber economy to a tourism economy after World War II, when business interests from Lewiston identified the lake as an ideal recreation site. Today its anchors include Brundage Mountain ski resort, Payette Lake recreation, Shore Lodge on Shellworth Beach, and the annual Winter Carnival, a week-long celebration with ice sculptures and live music that draws large seasonal crowds. The U.S. Forest Service operates a smokejumper base and air tanker base at the municipal airport, one of a small number of such facilities nationally. Ponderosa State Park, on a peninsula just outside town, provides old-growth forest and recreational access. The population has been growing steadily, and housing values have climbed sharply alongside that growth, with many units likely serving as second homes or vacation rentals given the resort character.
For a family considering this school, the housing market is a central practical factor. Typical home values in the school's zip code sit well above both the Idaho and national benchmarks, and the price-to-income ratio is elevated even by current national standards. Rent data was not available for this area, so we cannot speak to the rental market from the provided data. We looked for the district's strategic priorities or recent program changes and found little documented, so we leave that out rather than guess.
What the available evidence supports is this. Barbara R. Morgan Elementary delivers strong literacy instruction to a student body that is predominantly white and relatively advantaged, in a growing resort town where housing costs run high. A parent whose child is building early reading skills would find encouraging evidence in these results. A parent wanting to understand math instruction in the upper grades may want to look into this further with the school.
See more original research from School Decision →