The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in English language arts. The lowest is 64% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Payette Lakes Middle School
Payette Lakes Middle School sits in McCall, Idaho, serving grades six through eight as part of the McCall-Donnelly Joint School District. It is a regular public school, neither a charter nor a magnet, drawing from a community that blends year-round residents with a seasonal tourist population. The enrollment is modest for a middle school, with a student body that is predominantly white and a smaller Hispanic population. A small share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on students with individualized education programs and English learners was not reported, so those figures are unavailable here.
On state assessments, the most recent ISAT results paint a largely positive academic picture. English language arts is a clear strength. The large majority of sixth graders scored proficient or above, and that share rises sharply by seventh grade to a level that stands among the strongest results a middle school is likely to post. Eighth grade remains strong in ELA as well. Math performance is more varied across the grade levels. Seventh grade again leads, with most students proficient or above, while sixth grade sits noticeably lower. Eighth-grade math lands in a middling range. Science, tested only at eighth grade, shows a solid majority proficient or above. The pattern across subjects suggests seventh grade is a peak year at this school, and a parent might want to look into what happens between sixth and seventh that accounts for that jump.
No graduation rate applies here, since the school does not serve high school grades. Program offerings were not provided in the available data, so we cannot speak to electives, athletics, clubs, or advanced coursework. The same is true for staffing ratios, discipline data, attendance figures, and course-access details. Title I status was not reported. These gaps reflect what was and was not available rather than any judgment about the school's operations.
The setting matters for any family considering this school. McCall is a small resort town on the southern shore of Payette Lake, ringed by the Payette National Forest. Publicly reported sources describe a place that shifted from lumber to tourism after World War II, with Shore Lodge as an early anchor. Today the local economy runs on skiing at Brundage Mountain, lake recreation, and the annual Winter Carnival, which brings large seasonal crowds. The U.S. Forest Service maintains a smokejumper base and air tanker operation at the municipal airport, and the school district itself is a public-sector employer. State Highway 55, the Payette River Scenic Byway, is the single major road connecting McCall to Boise to the south.
Growth and housing costs shape the picture for families. Publicly reported data describes a population that has been climbing steadily, with substantial housing cost escalation over recent years. The typical home value in the school's zip code sits well above both the state and national benchmarks, and the price-to-income ratio is elevated. For a family moving into the area, buying a home here requires a larger financial commitment than in most of Idaho. Rental data was not available. Second homes and vacation rentals are a visible part of the housing stock, which is typical of a resort community and can affect year-round neighborhood stability.
The district brief turned up little on recent changes or strategic priorities, so there is nothing to relay on that front. No neighbor comparison data was provided for this school, so we cannot position it against nearby middle schools.
What the available evidence does say is that Payette Lakes Middle School delivers strong academic results in a distinctive setting. The ELA proficiency levels are genuinely high, and math and science are solid, with the sixth-grade math result the one area a parent might probe further. The community is small, outdoors-oriented, and growing more expensive. For a family already drawn to McCall by recreation or lifestyle, the school appears to be a sound academic fit through the middle grades. For a family weighing a move primarily for affordability, the housing market is the larger constraint.
See more original research from School Decision →