The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in English language arts. The lowest is 50% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Mcmillan Elementary
McMillan Elementary sits in West Boise, part of Joint School District No. 2, serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. It is a regular public school on the western side of a city that functions as Idaho's capital and economic center. Publicly reported sources describe Boise as home to major corporate headquarters including Micron Technology, Albertsons, and J.R. Simplot Company, alongside Boise State University and state government. The broader city has grown through sustained in-migration, with technology investment driving expansion across the Treasure Valley metro. Outside the downtown core and the Boise River Greenbelt corridor, the city trends auto-oriented and suburban, and McMillan's location on West McMillan Road places it in that suburban band.
The school is modest in size for an elementary serving its grade band, with enrollment distributed fairly evenly across grades. A slight majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, pointing to a working- and middle-class community rather than an affluent one. The student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic population forming the next largest group, and smaller shares of students identifying as Asian, Black, American Indian or Alaska Native, and two or more races. The data does not include information on English learners or students receiving special education services, so a parent would need to ask the school directly about those supports.
On state assessments, McMillan's results land in a middling range. Math proficiency across third, fourth, and fifth grades hovered around the midpoint, with a gentle upward tick from third to fifth grade that points in a positive direction. English language arts started stronger in third grade but then the reported ranges for fourth and fifth grade widened considerably, reflecting smaller tested groups and the uncertainty that comes with them. Science results for fifth graders sat right at about half proficient. Average scale scores were not available, and participation rates were not reported, so there is no way to compare how fully the student body was represented in these results. A parent may want to look into how the school supports students who are approaching proficiency, particularly in the upper elementary grades where the ELA ranges broaden.
The school does not have data on programs, staffing, discipline, attendance, or course access in the information provided. Title I status was not reported. No neighbor comparison data was available, so McMillan cannot be positioned against nearby schools in this profile. These gaps leave an incomplete picture of what enrichment, intervention, or specialized instruction the school offers beyond what the state testing results show. For a family weighing fit, those are good questions to bring to a tour or a conversation with the principal.
Housing in the school's zip code sits near the state benchmark for typical home values and above national figures. The price-to-income ratio is elevated, meaning buying a home here demands a larger share of income than in many parts of the country. Renting is comparatively manageable, with rent-to-income ratios landing below the threshold many financial advisors consider stretched. The gap between monthly rent and monthly mortgage costs is wide, so families who rent may find it easier to stay in the area than families trying to purchase. Home values in the zip code have been roughly flat year over year, while rents have crept up slightly.
The district, Joint School District No. 2, is one of the largest in the state, and publicly reported searches turned up little about recent parent-relevant changes, so there is nothing concrete to flag on that front.
What the assembled picture suggests is a neighborhood elementary school in a growing suburban part of Boise, serving a socioeconomically mixed population, with academic results that are steady if unspectacular. The missing data on programs, special populations, and school climate means a family would be wise to visit and ask pointed questions about how the school supports struggling readers and math learners, and what the day-to-day environment feels like for kids across the demographic spectrum the school serves.
See more original research from School Decision →