The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in English language arts. The lowest is 36% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on New Plymouth Elementary
New Plymouth Elementary sits at the center of a small agricultural community in Payette County, Idaho. The town was founded as a planned irrigation colony by the Plymouth Society of Chicago, and its distinctive horseshoe-shaped layout remains intact. Two curved streets wrap around a wide central park called The Boulevard, which runs the length of the residential area and includes a disc golf course along its west side. Irrigation ditches still parallel the roads, a reminder of the farming and orchard heritage that shaped the place. The school is part of the New Plymouth School District and serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school.
The community is predominantly White with a substantial Hispanic or Latino population. Agriculture remains a foundational economic activity, and the town promotes itself as combining farming, industry, history, and civic life. New Plymouth hosts the annual Payette County Fair and rodeo, and civic anchors include the Armoral Tuttle Public Library, the Veterans Memorial Building, the Senior Citizen Center, and a Kiwanis club. The town sits within the Ontario, Oregon micropolitan area, and many residents commute to Ontario or toward Boise for work. No public transit serves the area, so daily life is car-dependent. The town is experiencing modest, steady growth, and home values have appreciated markedly over recent years.
At the school, the enrollment is moderate for an elementary serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly White with a meaningful Hispanic or Latino presence and very small numbers from other racial or ethnic groups. Data on individualized education programs and English learner status was not available, so those dimensions of student support cannot be characterized here.
On Idaho's state assessments, English language arts stands as the stronger subject. Across the tested grades, a majority of third, fourth, and fifth graders reached proficiency or above, with the share holding steady from third grade through fifth. This is a solid result for a community school and suggests that literacy instruction is reaching most students.
Mathematics tells a different story. Fifth grade math proficiency was reported at well under half of tested students, and the third and fourth grade math results were suppressed into broad ranges rather than precise figures, making direct comparison difficult. What is visible suggests math outcomes lag behind reading. A parent may want to look into how the school approaches math instruction and intervention, particularly in the upper elementary grades. Fifth grade science proficiency was also reported only as a suppressed range, so that subject is hard to read from the public data.
Several fields that would help round out the picture were missing. Average scale scores were not reported for any tested grade or subject. Participation rates were unavailable. No civil rights, discipline, attendance, staffing, or course access data was provided. The school's locale classification and Title I status were also absent. These gaps limit the depth of comparison a family can make from publicly reported data alone.
The housing market around the school demands attention. Typical home values in the school's zip code sit above both the state and national benchmarks, and the area has seen meaningful appreciation. Estimated monthly mortgage costs run well above typical rents in the area, which may affect how families weigh buying versus renting. The price-to-income ratio is elevated relative to national norms, meaning local purchasing power is stretched compared with many parts of the country. Rental market data for the immediate area was not available, so the rental picture is incomplete.
We looked for recent district-level changes that might affect families, such as program shifts, facility projects, or leadership transitions, but found little of lasting impact in publicly available sources. The district brief turned up no major developments, so the account here rests on what the school and community currently show rather than on anticipated changes.
For a family considering New Plymouth Elementary, the picture is of a small-town school in a close-knit agricultural community with a distinctive physical identity. English language arts results are a genuine strength. Math is the area most worth asking questions about. The town offers a quiet, rural setting with modest growth and rising home values, situated within commuting distance of larger employment centers. The missing data fields mean a visit and direct conversation with school staff would help fill in what the public record does not yet show.
See more original research from School Decision →