The top reported proficiency rate is 18% in Math. The lowest is 17% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Mccain Middle School
McCain Middle School sits in Payette, a small city that serves as the county seat of Payette County in southwestern Idaho. The town hugs the mouth of the Payette River and functions as a commercial hub for the surrounding agricultural area, with a Main Street core anchored by the historic N.A. Jacobsen building. Payette sits within the Ontario, Oregon micropolitan area, and many residents commute across the Snake River for work. Publicly reported sources describe a compact community of roughly four square miles, connected by U.S. Highway 95 and Idaho State Highway 52, with the local economy built on retail trade, health care, social services, and accommodation and food services. County government employment is also present given Payette's role as county seat.
The school is part of Payette Joint District and has traditionally served grades six through eight. A publicly reported district reorganization in 2024 shifted McCain to a grade five through eight configuration after the board of trustees voted to close Westside Elementary and redistribute students. Payette Primary became a pre-kindergarten through grade four school. This change permanently altered feeder patterns and school assignments across the district. The current enrollment data still reflects a grade six through eight breakdown, which may capture a transitional year. A parent looking at McCain should confirm with the district how the grade reconfiguration has settled and whether fifth graders are now fully integrated into the building.
Academically, the most recent Idaho ISAT results paint a sobering picture. Grade five math and ELA proficiency rates, which likely reflect the newly added class, were both well below where most families would want to see them. For grades six through eight, the state suppressed exact proficiency figures, reporting only ranges. Those ranges sit low across every subject and grade, from single digits to roughly a third at the upper bound, with no grade clearing even the middle of the range. Science results tell a similar story, with no students reported as proficient in the grades where counts were available. Average scale scores were not reported. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, asking how leadership is responding to these results and what interventions are in place.
The student body is modest in size for a middle school. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals. The school's racial and ethnic composition is predominantly white, with a large Hispanic population representing a growing share of enrollment. Very small numbers of students identify as American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, or two or more races. Data on English learners and students with individualized education programs was not available, which limits the picture of how the school serves its special populations.
The district adopted a four-day school week in 2020, a structural change that persists and affects family routines and childcare needs. On the program side, the district has made a publicly reported investment in career and technical education, purchasing a former auto dealership to convert into a CTE center expected to open in the 2025 school year. Planned programs include automotive maintenance, collision repair, heavy equipment and diesel technology, and construction trades. While that facility will serve the broader district and may benefit McCain students as they advance toward high school, the middle school's own course access data was not available.
Housing in Payette is relatively affordable compared with state and national benchmarks. Typical home values sit below the Idaho median, and rents are modest. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home runs higher than local rent, which may push some families toward renting. The broader economic context includes a national unemployment rate holding steady, but local income data specific to Payette was limited in the materials reviewed.
What emerges is a school in transition, serving a working community with deep agricultural and small-town roots. The academic results are low, and a parent weighing McCain should ask pointed questions about how the district is addressing proficiency, how the new grade configuration is working, and what the four-day calendar means for student learning time and family logistics.
See more original research from School Decision →