The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in English language arts. The lowest is 12% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on West Carroll Middle School
West Carroll Middle School serves grades six through eight in Mount Carroll, a small rural county seat in Carroll County, Illinois. The school's enrollment is small, with about mid-sized-for-the-grade-band numbers distributed across each grade. The student body is predominantly white, with a smaller share of students identifying as Hispanic, multiracial, or other backgrounds. Demographic data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and special education or English learner enrollment are not available.
The school's recent state testing results reveal a pattern of low proficiency across tested subjects. In English language arts, sixth-grade proficiency sits around a third of students, while seventh and eighth grades show lower performance in the low- to mid-twenties. Mathematics proficiency is markedly weaker: sixth grade shows proficiency in the low teens, seventh grade in the mid-teens, and eighth grade around a tenth of students. Science assessment data for eighth grade indicates proficiency near a third of students; a parent may want to look into how math proficiency is being addressed across the middle grades, as the results suggest students are not meeting grade-level expectations at the rate the state anticipates.
Testing participation across grades has been high, with most grades showing near-complete participation rates. A parent who wants to understand the school's specific instructional approaches and supports in mathematics should connect directly with school leadership.
The school sits in Mount Carroll, a historic downtown county seat surrounded by older residential neighborhoods in the Illinois Driftless Area. The town has preserved 19th-century brick architecture, a modest downtown with shops and restaurants, and civic anchors including the county courthouse and public library. Most residents own their homes. Mount Carroll is not experiencing growth; the population has declined slowly over recent years, and the housing stock is older, reflecting the town's character as a historic place rather than an expanding one.
A significant district restructuring took effect for the 2025-26 school year. The high school relocated from nearby Savanna to the Mount Carroll middle school building, with middle school classes moving to Savanna's primary school. This change, driven by declining enrollment and aging facilities, permanently shifts which town serves each grade band. For families considering the district, this means middle school students now attend school in Mount Carroll rather than on a shared campus with the high school in Savanna.
When positioned against other districts in Carroll County, West Carroll Middle School's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades falls in the bottom quartile of the county comparison set. Housing values in the Mount Carroll zip code are modest relative to state and national benchmarks, and mortgage affordability is favorable for the local market. The local economy relies on manufacturing, health care, and retail; major employers include a CNC machining facility and county government offices. The town is car-dependent with no public transit and is small enough that most locations are walkable on foot.
See more original research from School Decision →