The top reported proficiency rate is 26% in English language arts. The lowest is 22% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Shields Elem School
Shields Elementary School is a regular public elementary school located in Chicago's southwest side, serving prekindergarten through fourth grade. The school has an enrollment of roughly a small-to-mid-sized school for its grade span, with the largest grade cohort in third grade. The student body is predominantly Hispanic, reflecting the neighborhood's demographic makeup, with a very small number of students from other racial and ethnic groups.
State assessment data from spring 2025 shows proficiency rates well below state and county baselines. In third-grade math, about a quarter of tested students reached proficiency, while fourth-grade math proficiency was lower still. Third-grade English language arts proficiency was comparable to math, and fourth-grade ELA performed somewhat better. The school's overall proficiency index across tested subjects and grades places it in the bottom quartile among the schools in its county comparison group. Science testing data for grades five and eight was not available; the school does not serve grades above four, so those grades do not apply.
The neighborhood surrounding the school is part of Chicago, a large, dense city with extensive public transit, lakefront access, and strong civic anchors including the Chicago Park District and a widely accessible library system. Chicago has been experiencing a return to population growth after nearly a decade of decline. The housing market in the area shows modest home values and rents that are increasing modestly year over year. The median home value in the school's zip code is in the mid-range, and monthly rent is moderate and climbing. According to affordability measures, the area is roughly aligned with cost-of-living challenges facing many Chicago residents.
Chicago Public Schools, the district serving this school, is in the midst of substantial structural and instructional change. The district has shifted from a mayor-appointed board to one that will be fully elected by November 2026, giving parents direct democratic input on governance. The district adopted a strategic plan in 2024 called "Together We Rise" that moves away from a school-choice model toward strengthening neighborhood schools, a significant reorientation. Last year the district launched new accountability dashboards to replace its former numeric school rating system, so the way schools are evaluated and compared has changed. The district has also rolled out Skyline, a comprehensive PreK-12 curriculum in English language arts, math, science, social science, world languages, and the arts; roughly half of district schools have adopted it, providing standardized instructional materials across the system for the first time in district history.
Shields serves as a neighborhood school within this district context. Assessment results show that students are not meeting grade-level proficiency benchmarks at rates typical of the county's schools. A parent weighing this school may want to look into further detail with the school about its instructional approach, the supports available for students below proficiency, and how the broader district curricular resources are being deployed in the building. The school's small upper-grade enrollment, particularly in fourth grade, is worth noting; families should confirm the school's trajectory and whether all grade levels remain stable.
See more original research from School Decision →