The top reported proficiency rate is 43% in English language arts. The lowest is 29% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Otter Creek Elem School
Otter Creek Elementary is a school of moderate size serving grades kindergarten through sixth in Elgin, with a student body that is close to half Hispanic, nearly a quarter white, and with substantial shares of Black and Asian students. The school draws from a growing neighborhood on Elgin's west side near the Randall Road and Hopps Road corridor, where new residential construction is concentrated and where median home values have climbed to a mid-range for Cook County in recent years.
The latest state test results show a pattern of steep decline across grade levels. In third-grade mathematics and English language arts, the school reaches proficiency in roughly the lower-to-mid range; by fourth grade, math proficiency drops by half; by fifth grade, both math and reading proficiency fall further; and by sixth grade, math proficiency reaches into the low range. Science results available only for fifth grade show proficiency in the low range as well. The school participates fully or nearly fully in testing across these grades, and test-taking rates were high enough to draw valid comparisons.
When positioned against other Kane County districts on overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades, Otter Creek falls below the median. The school's proficiency index places it in the lower half of the county's districts. This is the kind of result a parent may want to look into directly with the school to understand whether the decline reflects incoming student needs, staff or curriculum shifts, implementation of new instructional resources, or other factors affecting performance across grade bands.
On the positive side, the school sits in a district undergoing substantial transformation. A voter-approved bond in 2023 is funding rebuilds of five aging elementary schools, including schools in Elgin, and will also bring two newly built middle schools online by 2027, beginning with Hawk Hollow Middle School opening in 2025. The district is also rolling out extended school days across elementary schools starting in 2025-26 and shifting its middle grades to a 6-8 model with daily advisory periods for social-emotional learning and academic intervention, paired with new math and literacy curriculum. These structural and instructional changes are system-wide, which means Otter Creek families should expect continued evolution in schedules, teaching approaches, and school buildings over the coming years.
Elgin itself is in an active growth phase. New residential construction is concentrated in the Far West area near Hopps Road and Randall Road, where Otter Creek draws students. Downtown Elgin has anchors including the Gail Borden Library, the Hemmens Cultural Center, and three Metra stations connecting to Chicago. The city is adding apartments and performing arts space and is planning more mixed-use and residential development, so the school's neighborhood is likely to see continued population growth and changing composition.
Housing in the area is generally affordable relative to broader Cook County norms. Median home values sit at a low-to-mid range; median rent is modest. The affordability picture suggests families in this zone are often in their early or middle earning phases, which may correlate with school population diversity and the range of student needs staff encounter.
State data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility was not available for the school, and data on the share of English learners or students receiving special education services were also absent. These gaps leave a parent without direct visibility into the proportions of students in poverty or speaking home languages other than English, though the school's demographic makeup and Elgin's character as a multicultural city suggest both are meaningful. A parent interested in understanding the school's supports for these populations would benefit from asking the school directly about language programs, counseling, and academic intervention structures.
See more original research from School Decision →