The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in English language arts. The lowest is 26% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Mchenry Middle School
McHenry Middle School serves grades six through eight in McHenry, a mid-sized Fox River city northwest of Chicago, within McHenry CCSD 15. The school draws from a community with a blend of historic downtown storefronts, big-box retail corridors, and suburban residential neighborhoods. Housing values in the area sit somewhat above state benchmarks, with the local rental market at moderate rates relative to household income, creating a moderately affordable community context.
The school's academic performance shows a clear pattern across state-tested subjects. In English language arts, sixth and seventh graders show stronger proficiency, with seventh grade performing above the school's overall average. Eighth-grade ELA results and math results across all three grades sit notably lower. Sixth-grade math proficiency is below quarter-strength, as is performance in seventh and eighth grade. Eighth-grade science proficiency sits near the middle range. Participation rates across tested grades are very high, typically exceeding 98 percent. The overall proficiency index across tested subjects and grades places McHenry Middle in the bottom quartile when compared with other districts in McHenry County.
A parent may want to look into further with the school what specific instructional approaches or supports are in place to address the particularly low math proficiency, especially given that weakness appears consistent across all three grades. The strength in seventh-grade ELA is notable and worth understanding: whether that reflects particular teaching or student cohort characteristics could shape expectations for younger students moving through.
The school's student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Hispanic enrollment making up roughly a quarter of the school. Small numbers of students identify as Asian or Black. The racial composition reflects the broader McHenry community. State-mandated free and reduced price lunch data, special education enrollment, and English learner enrollment figures were not available.
McHenry Middle is a regular public school without charter or magnet designation. The school operates within a district context marked by significant recent change. In 2024-25, the district closed Landmark School, which had operated a unique year-round continuous learning calendar program since the early 1990s, making it a school-of-choice option in the county. That closure returned affected students to their home schools beginning the 2025-26 school year, eliminating an alternative pathway families in the district had relied on. The district also made a major capital decision to sell the Landmark building rather than invest the substantial sum that would have been required to bring it to modern standards, signaling where facility investment priorities lie going forward.
For families considering McHenry Middle, the profile reflects a school with uneven achievement across subjects and grade levels, particularly in mathematics, set within a district managing transitions in school options and capital allocation. The surrounding community offers moderate housing costs, stable employment anchored by healthcare and manufacturing, and riverfront civic life, though the district's recent choice to consolidate school options should factor into long-term enrollment planning.
See more original research from School Decision →