The top reported proficiency rate is 80% in English language arts. The lowest is 68% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Mill Street Elem School
Mill Street Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Naperville, a large suburban city west of Chicago with strong civic anchors, active downtown life centered on the Riverwalk, and steady residential growth. The school sits within Naperville CUSD 203, one of the district's elementary buildings, and draws from a broad cross-section of the community.
Academic performance shows mixed results across the tested grades. In math, third-graders attain solid proficiency, while fourth and fifth graders show declines; fifth grade math proficiency falls below third grade by a meaningful margin. Reading and language arts are stronger overall, with fifth grade posting notably higher proficiency than math and fourth grade outperforming third grade. Science proficiency, measured in fifth grade only, trails both math and ELA. Across all three subjects, fifth grade shows the widest variance: ELA strength paired with lower math and science performance. The school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among DuPage County school buildings, indicating it performs above the median for the county despite individual grade-level softness.
High test participation rates across grades suggest students are taking assessments, though state assessment data is limited to third through fifth grade because grades K-2 are not state-tested and grade six and above are not served by the school. One may want to look into whether the school has local benchmark data or other growth measures for younger grades or whether there are patterns the school attributes to instructional changes.
The enrollment is about a small-to-mid-size school for its grade band, with all grades represented and a slight bulge in grade two. The student body is racially and ethnically diverse: roughly half white, with meaningful shares identifying as Asian, Hispanic, and Black. English learner status and special education identification data are not publicly available, so a parent may want to contact the school directly about language supports and special education capacity.
The district is undertaking substantial curriculum and structural changes. A major K-12 literacy curriculum overhaul is underway, a multi-year investment to replace materials unchanged for many years. For middle and high grades, the district has approved new elective course structures and English learner program expansion at junior highs and high schools. Separate from Mill Street directly, the district is proposing an "Innovative School Experience" redesign of the school day that would extend the elementary day; that change is now targeted for the 2026-27 school year and has drawn both excitement and concern from families over scheduling and daily structure. Parents at Mill Street should stay informed about how these district-level shifts may land at their building.
Naperville itself is on a measured growth path. Population is rising modestly, with steady housing development, rising property values, and an active rental market. Downtown is walkable with strong community anchors including the Riverwalk, parks, and the Metra station, which are accessible to central Naperville families. The housing market is stable; rents and home values have risen incrementally year over year but inventory is robust. The area is affluent and employment-rich, with major employers spanning healthcare, distribution, energy, and education.
For a family in that area, Mill Street appears to offer solid elementary fundamentals with particular strength in upper-grade reading, some softness in math progression, and a racially mixed peer group. The school benefits from district-level investment in literacy instruction, though the pace and scope of coming changes warrant watching.
See more original research from School Decision →