The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Math. The lowest is 73% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Main Street Elementary School
Main Street Elementary School serves grades one through three in Shelbyville, a small county-seat city in rural central Illinois. The school sits within Shelbyville CUSD 4, a district that recently won voter approval for a significant capital project: a new pre-K-through-fourth-grade building to replace Main Street, along with improvements to other district facilities. For families considering this school, that referendum means Main Street's future is in transition. The bond will reshape where and how early-grade students are educated once construction completes, and local property tax bills will reflect the bond repayment for years to come.
The enrollment is modest, around mid-sized for an early-grade elementary school. A substantial share of the student body is white, with small numbers of students across other racial and ethnic groups. Data on free-or-reduced-price lunch eligibility and on special education or English learner populations was not available, so parents may want to ask the school directly about those demographics and the supports available.
On state testing, Main Street's third-grade cohort shows solid performance. In math, students achieved proficiency at a rate above the midpoint among the county's districts, placing the school in the top quartile for overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. In English language arts, the same cohort performed somewhat lower but still within a respectable range. Testing data was not available for grades four through eight because the school does not serve those grades; Illinois tests students in grades three and above, so only the third-grade results appear here.
The school's academic profile is anchored by the one grade that sits under state assessment. That single data point suggests the school is delivering baseline competency for most students in both reading and math. However, the evidence is thin: only third-grade results, no trend data, no comparison to prior years. Parents who want a fuller picture of how the school supports younger students, or how it prepares them for transition to middle grades, would benefit from visiting and asking teachers directly about early-literacy and numeracy practices in grades one and two.
The town of Shelbyville itself is a quiet county seat with a historic downtown centered around the courthouse square, where brick streets, shops, restaurants, and seasonal events draw foot traffic. Forest Park and the General Dacey Trail offer outdoor recreation; Lake Shelbyville, a major regional resource, lies nearby with beaches, marinas, and a visitor center. Civic anchors include the library and historical society. Growth in the area has been slow and steady decline rather than expansion; the city is more stable small-town anchor than growth corridor. Housing values are below state and national benchmarks, making the area relatively affordable. Employment is anchored by a hospital network, agribusiness, retail, and public-sector offices. Personal vehicles are essential; there is no fixed-route public transit.
For families with early-grade children, Main Street offers an established neighborhood school in a rural, low-growth setting with documented proficiency in state assessments. The pending transition to a new building introduces both opportunity and uncertainty. The school's specific strengths in classroom instruction, early intervention, or enrichment would be best explored with school staff and recent parent families.
See more original research from School Decision →