The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in English language arts. The lowest is 37% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Butler Elem School
Butler Elementary serves kindergarten through fifth grade in Springfield's South MacArthur corridor. The enrollment sits at a modest size across six grades, with a notably diverse student body: roughly half Black students, a third white, and the remainder distributed across Hispanic, multiracial, Asian, and Native Hawaiian students. The school does not report free-or-reduced-price-lunch counts or rates, and English learner and special education enrollment data are not available.
On state assessments administered in spring 2025, Butler's proficiency picture shows room for growth. In mathematics, third graders achieved mid-range performance, fourth graders slightly higher, and fifth graders the lowest of the three grades tested. English language arts results run somewhat ahead of math across the board: third-grade ELA proficiency sits at the midpoint, while fourth and fifth grades both exceed that mark. In science, fifth graders achieved just under half the proficiency threshold. Across tested grades and subjects, Butler's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint among districts in Sangamon County, meaning other elementary schools in the region show stronger performance on these same measures. All tested students participated in assessments; no participation issues were flagged.
The school sits in Springfield, the state capital, a mixed-income city anchored by government, healthcare, and education. Housing values in the 62704 zip code run modestly below state median, and rental costs follow a similar pattern relative to regional benchmarks. Affordability appears accessible on a per-income basis, though parents should verify the current housing market directly. The area is car-dependent; downtown Springfield offers genuine walkability, but most residential and school neighborhoods require a vehicle for daily errands.
At the district level, Springfield SD 186 has undertaken significant shifts. Starting in the 2024-2025 school year, the district adopted Benchmark Advance, a phonics-aligned reading curriculum anchored in science of reading principles, replacing prior approaches. This is a meaningful pedagogical change that shapes how every elementary student learns to read. Simultaneously, the district faces a substantial multi-year operating deficit tied to the end of federal COVID relief and flat state funding. In response, the board approved a deficit reduction plan that cuts elementary literacy coaches, right-sizes middle and high school staffing through attrition, scales back support programs, and places school closures on the table as a possibility. Parents should anticipate larger class sizes and reduced specialist and coaching staff over the coming years. Additionally, the district is exploring a new elementary school on the south side, which would open a new attendance option if it advances.
Butler operates within a context of academic transition and financial constraint. The adoption of a structured, phonics-based curriculum is a strength, positioning the school and its early readers for a research-aligned approach to literacy. The test data shows that students are learning but that the gap between Butler's current proficiency and peer schools in the county is real. A parent may want to look into the school's use of the Benchmark Advance materials, its approach to supplementing students who are not yet proficient, and how the staffing reductions are being managed at the building level.
See more original research from School Decision →