The top reported proficiency rate is 89% in English language arts. The lowest is 72% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Highcrest Middle School
Highcrest Middle School serves fifth and sixth grades in Wilmette, a stable North Shore suburb of Chicago with strong residential character and active civic life organized around the downtown Metra station and library. The school enrolls a small population, with the fifth-grade cohort roughly balanced with sixth grade, and draws from a community that is predominantly white with meaningful Asian and multiracial representation and a smaller Hispanic population. The student body reflects the town's economic profile: free-or-reduced-price lunch data were not reported, which in a district of Wilmette's means typically signals either very low participation or data suppression; a parent may want to look into this directly with the district.
Academic performance in the grades tested shows solid proficiency in English language arts and a somewhat softer picture in mathematics. In fifth-grade ELA, proficiency sits well above the midpoint among Cook County districts, and sixth-grade results remain quite strong. In math, fifth-grade proficiency is above the county median but with a noticeably lower gap than in reading, and sixth-grade math proficiency dips further. Science results from fifth grade are notably lower than either math or reading, positioning below the county median. Together, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the top quartile among Cook County districts, reflecting the strength of reading performance lifting the composite, but the math and science numbers suggest that students here may need closer attention in quantitative reasoning and science content. The data gaps are noteworthy: state testing results for seventh and eighth grades are missing, which is consistent with the school's actual grade configuration—it serves only fifth and sixth grades despite the state assessment system testing through eighth—so no multi-year trend is available.
The school sits within a district that has recently undergone significant transition. District 39 operated half-day kindergarten as its standard for decades and required families to pay an optional fee (reduced to around [amount] annually) for a full-day enrichment program called KEEP39 if they wanted a complete school day. That model has created real household-budget and enrollment-choice friction for families weighing Wilmette against neighboring districts. The district is moving to full-day academic kindergarten beginning Fall 2025, which will remove this cost barrier and childcare complication.
Highcrest sits in a town experiencing mature suburban redevelopment. Wilmette is fully built, with growth driven by infill and teardowns rather than new subdivisions, and is currently navigating significant transit-oriented development downtown. Two major luxury residential projects are underway just blocks from the Metra station: a rental building that opened fully leased in 2023, and a for-sale condo project approved for late 2026 groundbreaking. The town remains quiet and family-oriented, with low-key civic life anchored by parks, a well-used library, and the Metra connection to Chicago, but has attracted pushback from residents favoring preservation of its historic residential character. Housing values in the Wilmette 60091 zip code are substantial, reflecting the North Shore's market position, and the rental market is similarly high. The area has moved from substantial housing supply into a more typical balance, with rents climbing.
Test participation was near universal in both grades tested, so engagement with assessment appears consistent. Beyond the state testing data provided, information about special populations, staffing, advanced coursework, cocurricular programs, or attendance patterns was not available. A parent considering this school would benefit from discussing directly with the district what support structures exist for students whose math and science proficiency trails their reading gains, and what the full kindergarten transition means for the broader elementary experience families will encounter in the years before Highcrest.
See more original research from School Decision →