The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in Math. The lowest is 4% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Circle City Preparatory Elementary School
Circle City Preparatory Elementary School is a public charter school in Indianapolis, part of the Circle City Prep Charter School district. It serves kindergarten through seventh grade and operates as a regular school. The school is located on the east side of the city, in the 46226 zip code. Because it is a charter school, it operates under an authorization agreement with the Indiana Charter School Board rather than a traditional school district. A charter renewal application was submitted in 2020, and the school expanded its grade span to include kindergarten through seventh grade by the 2023‑2024 school year, offering families a continuous K‑8 pathway within a single charter organization.
The student body is small for a school serving that grade band. Every student at Circle City Prep qualifies for free or reduced‑price lunch, which signals that the school serves a highly disadvantaged population. The racial and ethnic composition is overwhelmingly Black, followed by a substantial Hispanic share, with only a handful of white students and a few multiracial or Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students. Data on students with disabilities and English learners were not available in the records reviewed, so a parent would want to ask the school directly about how it supports those groups.
On the academic side, state test results from the ILEARN assessments place this school clearly below the midpoint among Marion County districts when overall proficiency is averaged across tested subjects. Proficiency rates in math, English language arts, science, and social studies are all low. The percentages of students scoring at the proficient or above level are modest in math, lower in English language arts, and quite small in science and social studies. These results reflect the challenges of serving a student population that enters school with high needs. A parent considering this school would want to ask about the specific academic interventions, tutoring, or curriculum supports the school uses to raise achievement. The school’s high participation rates on the tests mean the results are a fair representation of what students know.
Because the school does not serve high school grades, there is no graduation rate to report. Chronic absenteeism data were also missing from the available records, so families should inquire about attendance patterns, especially given the link between regular attendance and academic progress in elementary and middle school.
The housing market in the school’s zip code reflects a more affordable corner of the Indianapolis area. Home values are below the state median and well below the national median, and rents are moderate. This is a part of the city where many working families can find housing, but the economic context is tight: the national unemployment rate has been stable near 4.3 percent, and mortgage rates have hovered around 6.5 percent, which affects how far a household’s income goes. Real median household income nationally has increased modestly in recent years, but the school’s 100 percent free‑lunch rate shows that local families are living on significantly less.
Who this school fits. Circle City Prep Elementary is a choice for Indianapolis families who want a charter school with a K‑8 structure, one that serves a predominantly Black and Hispanic student body and that has committed to expanding its grade offerings over time. The school is open to all students in the area through the charter application process. The academic results are plainly low, and a family would want to look into this further with the school: what the school’s own growth data show, what curricula it uses, and what tutoring or extended‑learning programs exist. The school’s high‑poverty context means that state test comparisons do not tell the whole story; many schools serving similar populations face the same stubborn outcomes. A parent who values a small, single‑site K‑8 charter and who is prepared to be an active partner in pushing for higher achievement may find this school worth a close look.
See more original research from School Decision →