The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in Math. The lowest is 6% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Emma Donnan Elementary and Middle
Emma Donnan Elementary and Middle is a public charter school in Indianapolis serving kindergarten through eighth grade. It operates as part of Adelante Schools, a single-school charter district. The school is located in the southern portion of the city, and families considering it should understand that this is a school where the academic numbers are low and the student body faces significant economic disadvantage, alongside a notable strength in student attendance on test days.
The student population is diverse and predominantly comes from low-income households. A very large share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The racial and ethnic composition shows a mix, with the largest groups being Black students, followed by white and Hispanic students. The school's enrollment is modest for a K-8 building, and class sizes through the grade span vary. The neighborhood's housing market, measured by typical home values and rents in the zip code, sits below the national median, and home values have been flat to slightly declining in recent months, consistent with a more affordable part of the city.
On state assessments, the school's results are among the lowest in the state. In math, about a quarter of students met the state's proficiency standard. In English language arts, about one in five students did. Science proficiency was substantially lower, and at the fifth-grade level, social studies proficiency was below one in ten. The school's overall proficiency index across all tested subjects and grades sits at the midpoint of districts in Marion County, which is a large urban county with many districts that post very low scores as well as some that perform much higher. A parent reading these numbers will see that the vast majority of students are not meeting grade-level benchmarks. This is the central academic reality of the school. State testing data does not capture student growth, and the school may be making progress with students who arrive behind; those data were not available in this profile. Parents who want to understand how the school measures progress over time should ask the school directly.
The school meets an important threshold for reliability: student participation rates on the math and English language arts tests were effectively complete, meaning the proficiency figures are not skewed by missing data. This is a positive sign for data integrity. However, chronic absenteeism and graduation rate data are not applicable here because the school does not serve high school grades, and data on special education and English learner populations were not reported in the profile. A family with a child who has an individualized education plan or is learning English may want to contact the school to understand the support structures in place.
A parent should know that this is a charter school, which means it operates with some autonomy from the local school district. Adelante Schools, the charter authorizer and operator, was formed relatively recently, and a search for recent district-level changes such as policy shifts, curriculum overhauls, or facility investments turned up no publicly reported items that meet a lasting-impact bar, so this profile cannot speak to any specific recent developments at the school level. The school's website is listed in the profile for families who want current information on programs, after-school activities, and field trips.
Emma Donnan Elementary and Middle is best understood as a high-poverty, high-need school where state test scores are very low. For a family whose priority is a school with strong academic outcomes as measured by standardized tests, this is not that school. For a family already living in the neighborhood who values a local school where students do show up, and who is prepared to supplement learning at home or seek additional academic support, it may be worth a visit to see the environment firsthand. The data in this profile provides a clear picture of the academic challenge without offering a verdict on whether the school is a good fit for any particular child; that depends on what a family is looking for and what alternatives are available in a large city like Indianapolis.
See more original research from School Decision →