The top reported proficiency rate is 15% in English language arts. The lowest is 6% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Benjamin Franklin Elementary Sch
Benjamin Franklin Elementary School is a regular public school in Whiting, Indiana, serving students from pre-kindergarten through sixth grade. It is part of the School City of Hammond district, a system that covers a broader urban area along the Lake Michigan shoreline in Lake County. Whiting itself is a compact, older industrial city dominated by the BP Whiting Refinery, the largest oil refinery in the Midwest, and its population has been in steady decline for nearly a century. The school sits within a grid of residential streets, close to the business district on 119th Street, and shares a ZIP code with the adjacent Hammond neighborhood of Robertsdale.
The school’s enrollment is moderate for an elementary serving this grade span. The student body is majority Hispanic, with a substantial white and Black presence and a small share of multiracial students. More than half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, indicating a community of predominantly lower-income households. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not reported in the available state data, so a parent should confirm those counts directly with the school if they are relevant.
Academically, the most concrete evidence comes from the Indiana ILEARN assessments, given in grades three through six. Across all tested subjects, proficiency rates are well below the midpoint among Lake County’s elementary schools. In math, a low single-digit share of students met the state’s proficiency standard. In English language arts, the result was similarly low, and the proficiency rate for science was about on par with that. The most pronounced gap was in social studies, where a very small share of tested fifth graders scored proficient or above. These numbers point to a school where most students are not yet performing at grade level, and a parent considering this school would want to understand what academic interventions, supports, and curricula are in place. The school’s overall proficiency index, a composite of all tested subjects and grades, places it below the midpoint relative to other districts in the county.
The school building itself serves grades through sixth, after which students would feed into a middle school within the School City of Hammond system. Whiting’s own high school is served by a separate district, School City of Whiting, so the feeder pattern is worth clarifying early. No data on course access, staffing ratios, chronic absenteeism, or discipline were available in this profile, so a family should request a school handbook, tour the building, and ask about class sizes, specials, and enrichment.
Whiting’s housing market offers relatively affordable entry points. Median home values are modest, below both the Indiana state benchmark and the national figure, and rents are also below national medians. The city’s long-term population decline and the recent closure of the Mascot Hall of Fame, a downtown attraction, signal a community that is not currently growing or attracting new development. For a family, that stability may be appealing or limiting depending on what they want. The compact, walkable grid of 119th Street and the lakefront parks provide amenities within a short distance of the school.
This is a school where the primary academic challenge is clear from the state data. A family whose priority is high measured proficiency should weigh that heavily. For a family looking for a small, community-rooted elementary in a blue-collar lakeside town where housing is relatively affordable, and who are prepared to advocate for academic support and enrichment, Benjamin Franklin Elementary is a school that warrants a close visit and direct conversations with the principal and teachers.
See more original research from School Decision →