The top reported proficiency rate is 50% in Social studies. The lowest is 41% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Sheridan Elementary School
Sheridan Elementary School serves students from prekindergarten through fifth grade as the primary elementary school for Sheridan Community Schools, a small district in the far northwest corner of Hamilton County. The school enrolls a large student body for this grade band and draws from the town of Sheridan, a place that is historically a small agricultural and manufacturing community but is now growing quickly. The downtown retains a traditional Main Street feel, including a Carnegie library and a historic district listed on the National Register, yet the town is also auto-dependent and lies roughly an hour’s drive from downtown Indianapolis. The population has risen briskly since the last census, and in early 2025 the town consolidated with the surrounding Adams Township, a structural change that reflects ongoing growth. The district itself offers open enrollment at no cost to any Indiana student, a policy that makes the school accessible to families living outside the traditional attendance boundary.
In terms of student profile, the school enrolls a population that is predominantly white, with small numbers of Hispanic and multiracial students and very few Asian or Black students. Just under half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which places the school in a moderate range of economic disadvantage for Hamilton County, a county that overall is quite affluent. Housing values in the local zip code sit meaningfully above the state average but below the national average, and the local unemployment rate has been low and stable.
Academically, Sheridan Elementary’s state test results are mixed. On the ILEARN assessments in math and English language arts, the share of students scoring proficient or above trailed the median among Hamilton County districts. Math proficiency was below the county midpoint, though it was above the lowest-performing schools in the county, and English language arts proficiency also sat below the county median. In science, proficiency for the elementary grades tested was lower still. Social studies, tested only at fifth grade, showed a proficiency rate around the halfway mark. The school’s overall proficiency index across all tested subjects and grades, which averages the available subject rates, placed it below the midpoint among Hamilton County’s elementary schools.
These numbers point to a school where academic performance, on the whole, is not as strong as what many Hamilton County families will find in the district’s more suburban communities to the south and east. A parent looking at this profile may want to ask the school about specific instructional supports, reading and math intervention programs, and how the school is addressing these results. Because the school serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate or college-career readiness data to consider; those metrics apply to the high school level, not this building. Chronic absenteeism data was also not available in the source material, so it is not possible to say whether attendance patterns are a factor in the academic picture.
The district operates a compact set of schools within the town, so Sheridan Elementary is integrated into the community rather than on a remote campus. The school is a regular public school with no charter or magnet status, and Title I status was not reported in the data provided. Program offerings and course access details were also absent from the available sources, leaving a gap for families who want to know about enrichment, arts, or specialized instruction at the elementary level.
For a family weighing this school, the central trade-off is between a small-town, growing community with a strong historic identity and test scores that are below the county norm. The town itself is in a period of expansion, and the district’s open-enrollment policy means that even families who do not live in Sheridan can choose this school. Whether the academic pathway fits a child will depend on the level of challenge a family seeks and the specific supports the school provides. The data available does not answer whether those supports are robust, so a visit and a conversation with the principal would be a reasonable next step.
See more original research from School Decision →