The top reported proficiency rate is 76% in Math. The lowest is 41% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Olive Township Elementary School
Olive Township Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade as part of the New Prairie United School Corporation in New Carlisle, Indiana. The school is one of three district campuses located in this small town, which sits within the South Bend–Mishawaka metropolitan area. New Carlisle has a compact historic downtown along Michigan Street, with locally-owned shops, dining, a library, and a historic district listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Beyond the core, the town has seen significant industrial and commercial growth, including a large Amazon data center, a solar generating station, and the Indiana Enterprise Center industrial park. The schools themselves are not integrated into the downtown but serve a broader district area that draws from a surrounding population well beyond the town's residents. No public transit currently serves New Carlisle, and the closest commuter rail stop is in neighboring Hudson Lake.
Academically, Olive Township Elementary posts strong results on the state's ILEARN assessments. In math, a large majority of students met or exceeded state standards. In English language arts, more than three out of five students scored proficient or above. Science performance was on a similar level. Social studies, tested only in fifth grade, saw a lower share of students reaching proficiency, a finding a parent may want to discuss with the school regarding support in that subject area. Overall, the school's proficiency index across tested subjects places it among the highest-performing elementary schools in St. Joseph County when compared district by district. The school has a moderate-sized enrollment for a K-5 building. The student body is predominantly white, with a small number of Hispanic students and an even smaller number of Black students; the remaining share is two or more races. More than a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a context that is relevant for families considering the range of support services available.
The school does not serve grades that produce a graduation rate, and no chronic absenteeism data was available for this report. The district brief indicated no recent major changes such as referenda, curriculum shifts, or bond measures that would be of high interest to parents, though that does not mean nothing has occurred — simply that nothing surfaced in the search. The housing market in the area, reflected through the town's ZIP code, shows typical home values somewhat above the state average, with rents on the lower side relative to national benchmarks, giving the area a moderate cost-of-living profile.
For a family considering this school, the takeaway is straightforward. Olive Township Elementary offers consistently above-average academic performance on state tests relative to other elementary schools in the county, particularly in math and English. The school is situated in a town that combines a small historic downtown with a growing industrial and commercial base, which has brought large employers and infrastructure investment to the area. The student population is not highly diverse, and a notable share of families come from lower-income households. The school's academic strength, its manageable size, and its role within the New Prairie district make it a solid option for families seeking a high-performing elementary school in a community that is experiencing economic development but retains a small-town character.
See more original research from School Decision →