The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Science. The lowest is 57% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Fillmore Elementary School
Fillmore Elementary School is a small, regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in the rural town of Fillmore, Indiana. It is part of the South Putnam Community Schools district. The school is located on Main Street, integrated into the town’s small civic center alongside the town hall and post office, rather than on a separate campus.
The student body is predominantly white, reflecting the demographics of the surrounding community. Just over half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a rate that indicates a moderate level of economic need among the families served. Enrollment is small across all grades, creating an environment where students and staff are likely to know one another well.
On the 2024-25 state assessments, Fillmore Elementary recorded proficiency rates that stood apart from other districts in Putnam County. The school’s overall performance across tested subjects and grades was in the top quartile compared to districts in the county. In math, a strong majority of students scored at or above the proficient level. In English language arts, proficiency was somewhat lower, though still above the midpoint for the county. Science and social studies results, which come from a smaller cohort of fifth graders, showed a solid majority of students meeting the proficiency standard.
State testing data for special education and English learner populations was not available in the data provided, so a parent may want to ask the school directly how those students are progressing and what supports are in place.
As an elementary-only school, there is no graduation rate to report. The school operates within a district that, according to publicly reported information, recently approved a new STEM initiative for elementary and middle school students beginning in the 2024-2025 school year, which may influence the curriculum at Fillmore Elementary. The high school also completed a facilities improvement project in 2023, but that does not directly affect the elementary campus.
The town of Fillmore is a low-density rural community with limited commercial activity. It is located roughly 45 miles west of Indianapolis and a short drive from Greencastle, giving residents access to more services and employment centers. Housing values in the area are below the state median, and the market has seen modest appreciation. The town is experiencing slow, steady population growth, but no major new housing developments or commercial projects were identified in searches.
For a family living in or moving to this part of Putnam County, Fillmore Elementary offers an academically competitive option for elementary-age children in a small-town setting. The school’s test results suggest students are performing well relative to county peers, particularly in math and science. The small enrollment and single-site elementary structure mean the school serves as a central community institution on Main Street. Parents who value a rural, tight-knit school environment with above-average academic outcomes may find this a natural fit, while those looking for a more diverse student body or a wider array of enrichment programs may want to explore what the district offers at the middle and high school levels.
See more original research from School Decision →