The top reported proficiency rate is 65% in Social studies. The lowest is 16% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Otter Creek Middle School
Otter Creek Middle School is a regular public school serving grades six through eight in Terre Haute, Indiana, within the Vigo County School Corporation. It sits on the north side of the city, near the edge of a mid-sized place that blends a college-town fabric with a legacy of industrial manufacturing and government anchors. Indiana State University is integrated into downtown Terre Haute, Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology sits just east of the city, and Ivy Tech Community College also maintains a campus. The local economy includes diversified manufacturing in the Vigo County Industrial Park, the Federal Correctional Complex, and a casino that opened on the east side in spring 2024. A downtown convention center completed a few years ago, an Arts Corridor, and a children's museum add to the civic landscape. The district’s recent parent-relevant changes were not publicly documented in a way that yields a clear account, so none are reported here.
State testing results from the ILEARN assessment for the most recent school year show that a minority of students reached proficiency. In English language arts, roughly a fifth of students scored at the proficient or above level. In mathematics, the share was lower, about a sixth. In science, which is tested only in one grade at this level, around a third of students met the bar. A social studies result from several years ago, based on a different assessment, showed a higher figure, but that data is too old and from a different test to be a reliable measure of current performance. The school’s assessment participation rates were high across both ELA and math, which means the results reflect nearly all enrolled students. These proficiency rates are below where many families would hope to see them, and a parent considering this school may want to inquire with the school or district about how they are addressing academic support and improvement.
Enrollment at Otter Creek Middle School is substantial for a middle school, with students fairly evenly distributed across sixth, seventh, and eighth grades. The student body is predominantly white. A meaningful share of students are of two or more races, and smaller shares are Hispanic, Black, or Asian. More than six in ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating that a majority of families face some economic pressure. This share is high and worth noting as context for the school’s resource needs. Data on students receiving special education services and English learner support were not available in the provided information, so it is not possible to comment on those populations here.
The housing market around Otter Creek Middle School reflects typical costs for the area, with home values modestly below the state median and well below the national figure. Monthly mortgage payments on a median-priced home are in the mid-hundreds range, and the rent-to-income ratio is reasonably manageable, which may be relevant for families weighing their housing options against school quality.
The school’s position relative to other districts in Vigo County could not be established because the comparison group was too small to produce meaningful metrics, so no local benchmark is available for overall proficiency or other indicators. The school is part of a district that covers all of Vigo County, which means families live in a mix of city, suburban, and rural settings within the same attendance boundaries.
In sum, Otter Creek Middle School serves a large, majority-white, economically diverse student body in a city with a stable population and a mixed economy. Its academic proficiency numbers are low, particularly in math and ELA, which is the most important fact for a family assessing whether the school meets their student’s needs. The broader Terre Haute community offers a range of cultural and educational institutions, but the school itself shows a clear gap between where its students are performing and where state standards set the bar. A parent would want to understand what intervention or enrichment programs are in place before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →