The top reported proficiency rate is 42% in Math. The lowest is 27% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Nathan Hale Elementary School
Nathan Hale Elementary School serves students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Whiting, a small industrial city on the shore of Lake Michigan. The school is part of the School City of Whiting, the district that serves the entire community. Whiting is dominated by the BP Whiting Refinery, the largest oil refinery in the Midwest, and the city’s population has been declining steadily for decades. The business district along 119th Street is walkable, and the city’s compact grid means schools and civic life are interwoven rather than isolated on large campuses. The district itself reports no recent major changes that would alter the day-to-day experience for families.
Nathan Hale is a regular public school, neither a charter nor a magnet, and it enrolls a student body that is predominantly Hispanic. A substantial share of students come from low-income households, as measured by free and reduced-price lunch eligibility. The school is sizable for an elementary building, with enrollment that supports a full range of grade-level classrooms. The student population is diverse in background but relatively homogeneous in the sense that the large majority of students share a Hispanic heritage, creating a distinct cultural peer environment.
Academically, the school’s performance on Indiana’s ILEARN assessments places it above the midpoint among the scores of districts in Lake County when looking at overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. That is a meaningful point of comparison, as it suggests that Nathan Hale’s students, as a group, are performing better than many of their peers in the county. Still, the actual proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science are in a range that many families would consider modest: roughly two out of five students reached the proficient or above level in each of those subjects. Social studies results, which are tested only in fifth grade, were lower, with about one in four students meeting the proficient bar. A parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand how the curriculum and instructional supports are structured, particularly for social studies.
Because the school serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and chronic absenteeism data was not available in the materials provided. Similarly, information on special education and English learner populations was missing, which is a gap a prospective parent would want to fill by asking the school directly. Without those figures, it is hard to gauge the full scope of student support services.
The school environment data, including staffing ratios and discipline incidents, was also absent from the data sources used here. That leaves an incomplete picture of day-to-day conditions inside the building. Families considering Nathan Hale should seek out current information on class sizes, teacher experience, and any programs for students who need extra help.
On the housing side, Whiting offers home values that are below both the state and national benchmarks, making it a relatively affordable option in the Chicago region. Rents also come in at a modest level, which may matter for families weighing where to live. The long-term population decline in the city suggests a stable but not growing housing market, and no major new developments were surfaced in the search results.
For a family looking at Nathan Hale, the school offers a solid, if unremarkable, academic profile relative to other schools in Lake County. The peer environment is shaped by a predominantly Hispanic student body and a high rate of economic need. The setting is a close-knit, older industrial town with a walkable downtown and strong civic anchors like the public library and lakefront parks. The school itself is a straightforward neighborhood elementary, and the district has not made any recent changes that would disrupt routines. The main open questions are around student support services, staffing, and the social studies curriculum, all of which are worth a direct conversation with the school.
See more original research from School Decision →