The top reported proficiency rate is 19% in English language arts. The lowest is 15% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Martin Luther King Jr. Charter School of Excellence
Martin Luther King Jr. Charter School of Excellence is a K-5 charter school in Springfield, Massachusetts. It operates as its own district, meaning it functions independently from the city’s traditional public school system. The school is located on Dorset Street in the Forest Park area of the city, a neighborhood of Victorian homes and tree-lined blocks near one of the largest urban parks in New England. The school’s grade span is short – only kindergarten through fifth grade – so parents sending a child here will need to plan for a middle school placement after fifth grade, as the charter does not extend upward.
On the state’s NextGen MCAS assessments, the school’s overall proficiency rates were low across math, English language arts, and science in the most recent testing year. The share of students scoring at the proficient or advanced level in each subject was below a fifth of those tested. This placed the school in the bottom quartile among districts in Hampden County on a combined index of tested subjects. The trend data show that the school’s proficiency rates were markedly higher in years before the pandemic – in math, for example, rates were above two-fifths in 2018-19 – and then dropped sharply in 2020-21 and have not recovered to their earlier levels. The most recent year shows some uptick from the pandemic nadir, but rates remain well below the county median.
The student body is made up almost entirely of children who identify as Hispanic or Black, with a small number of other racial backgrounds. The school is a charter, so it does not have a geographic attendance boundary; families choose to apply, and if oversubscribed, admission is by lottery. Data on economic disadvantage, special education status, and English learner status were not available in the records used here. A parent considering this school may want to ask the school directly about the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch and about the supports available for students with disabilities or those learning English, as those factors often shape the academic context.
The school’s district – which is the charter itself – recently adopted Amplify Science as its core science curriculum for all K-5 students, according to the state’s curriculum dashboard. This is an inquiry-based, standards-aligned program. The school does not offer high school coursework or graduation pathways, as it ends at fifth grade. There were no property-tax or referendum items to report, because charter districts in Massachusetts do not hold those kinds of votes.
Springfield is the urban center of western Massachusetts, a city of Victorian architecture, riverfront parks, and a mix of manufacturing, insurance, health care, and entertainment employers. Housing values in the school’s ZIP code are well below the state median but have risen moderately recently, and rents have increased notably. The city itself experienced economic decline in the late 20th century and has seen public and private reinvestment in recent decades, including a casino development and transit hub renovation. The school sits in a residential part of the city, not in the dense downtown core.
For a parent weighing this school, the central fact is that state test scores are low compared with those in the county and the state. The school serves a population that historically has faced resource gaps, and the scores reflect that challenge. The charter offers an alternative to the city’s traditional elementary schools, with a focused K-5 structure and a new science curriculum. The question is whether the school provides the academic momentum and support that a particular child needs, especially given that the scores are far below typical benchmarks. A parent may want to visit, ask about literacy and math interventions, and learn how the school is working to lift achievement from the current levels.
See more original research from School Decision →