The top reported proficiency rate is 24% in English language arts. The lowest is 11% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Trotter Elementary School
Trotter Elementary School is a regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through sixth grade, located in the Dorchester neighborhood of Boston. It is part of Boston Public Schools, one of the largest urban districts in Massachusetts. The school's enrollment is moderate for an elementary building, with students spread fairly evenly across the grade levels. The student body is predominantly Black and Hispanic, with smaller shares of white, Asian, and multiracial students. The share of students from immigrant backgrounds is likely high, given that Dorchester is Boston's most diverse neighborhood, where nearly one in three residents is foreign-born and many languages are spoken at home.
Academically, state assessment results for the most recent testing year show that proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science are all well below the midpoint when compared with other districts in Suffolk County. The proficiency index, which averages across tested subjects and grades, places the school below the midpoint of the county's districts. In math, the share of students scoring proficient or above is low, while in ELA it is somewhat higher, though still below what many families would hope for. Science results, which are tested at grade five, show a similar pattern. Multi-year trends reveal that performance has fluctuated: before the pandemic, proficiency rates in both math and ELA were higher than they are now, though never at a high level. The pandemic brought sharp drops, and while scores have recovered some ground since the lowest point, they have not returned to pre-pandemic levels. A parent considering Trotter may want to ask the school about the specific academic supports available, especially in math, and how the school is working to raise achievement.
The school serves only elementary and early middle grades, ending at sixth grade, so there is no graduation rate to report. No data was available on the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals, students with disabilities, or English learners. Discipline, attendance, and staffing information also were not provided. A parent may wish to follow up with the school directly on these topics.
Dorchester itself is a large, dense urban neighborhood with a strong sense of community. It is not a single downtown but a constellation of commercial squares — Fields Corner, Uphams Corner, Codman Square, and others — each with its own character and civic life. Public transit is readily available via the MBTA Red Line and the Mattapan Trolley, making the school accessible for families who rely on the subway or bus. The neighborhood has miles of waterfront, parks such as Franklin Park and Pope John Paul II Park, and multiple branches of the Boston Public Library. Housing costs in the area are high relative to national averages, with home values above the typical national level and rents that consume a large share of household income. This is an expensive place to live, and families may feel the pressure of housing costs.
The comparison with other districts in Suffolk County clarifies that Trotter's overall proficiency is below the midpoint. That does not mean the school lacks strengths — only that on this particular metric it falls in the lower half of a county that includes both high-performing exam schools and many urban schools facing similar challenges. The school serves a multilingual, multicultural student population in a neighborhood that is both historic and rapidly evolving. Growth and development are ongoing along Dorchester Avenue and around transit stops, bringing new families and new investment even as gentrification raises concerns for longtime residents.
For a family that values a neighborhood school within walking distance of home in a diverse urban setting, and that is comfortable with a school where test scores are modest and the focus may be on foundational skills and community connections, Trotter Elementary could be a reasonable option. The academic data is clear, and a parent will want to understand what interventions and enrichment are in place before making a decision. The missing information on special programs and support services is a gap worth filling with a direct conversation at the school.
See more original research from School Decision →