The top reported proficiency rate is 60% in Science. The lowest is 36% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on John F Kennedy
John F. Kennedy Elementary School in Holbrook, Massachusetts, serves children from pre-kindergarten through grade five. This is a regular public school and one of two schools in the Holbrook district, sharing a single campus with the middle-high school. For a family new to the area, the school's setting and structure are straightforward: a single elementary school feeding into a single secondary school, all on one site. This simplicity removes the guesswork around school choice within the district, but it also means every elementary-age child in town attends this one building.
The school enrollment is substantial for an elementary school. The student body is diverse. A little under half of the students are white, roughly a quarter are Black, and about a fifth are Hispanic. Asian students and students identifying with two or more races each make up a modest share of the population. The school does not report the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, nor does it report the share of students with individualized education plans or English learner classifications, so a parent cannot assess the school's economic or special-education profile from the available data. A family for whom these factors matter should expect to ask the school directly.
On state testing, the picture is mixed and shows a clear pattern over time. Recent results from the Massachusetts Next-Generation MCAS, which tests students in grades three through eight, place John F. Kennedy below the midpoint for overall proficiency when compared to other districts in Norfolk County. In the most recent testing year, just over a third of students scored proficient or above in both English language arts and mathematics. The science results were higher, with a strong majority of students reaching proficiency, though science is tested in only one elementary grade. Looking across the past several years, a long-term downward trend is visible. In English language arts, proficiency rates were around half or slightly above half in the years before the pandemic, then declined to the current level. In math, the pattern is more volatile. The school recorded relatively high proficiency before 2020, dropped sharply in the first pandemic testing year, regained ground in the two years after, and then declined again to its current level. A parent considering the school should be aware that while the most recent data is a point in a longer arc, the arc has generally been moving the wrong direction. There is no graduation rate to consider here, as the school does not serve high school grades.
The housing context in and around Holbrook adds another dimension. The area commands a home value that sits above the national benchmark but somewhat below the Massachusetts state benchmark. The county's housing market shows active listings, a high volume of new and pending listings, and a median listing price in a range that makes homeownership a serious investment. Monthly mortgage costs on a typical home would be a meaningful portion of household income. Rents are not dramatically cheaper than a mortgage, and the estimated difference between renting and buying is narrow, so both paths carry similar financial weight. For a family looking to move into the district, the housing market is expensive and competitive, which shapes who can afford to live in the attendance zone.
The town of Holbrook itself is a primarily residential commuter community. Most residents who work commute to Boston, and local employment is concentrated in service industries. The town has commuter rail service connecting to South Station, which matters for a parent who works in the city. The schools sit on a shared campus rather than in a traditional downtown district, so the school experience is somewhat set apart from any town-center activity.
The district underwent a major consolidation in the recent past, collapsing three older school buildings into two new ones on a single site. John F. Kennedy Elementary now serves all of Holbrook's elementary students in one building, a change that simplified the district's footprint but also concentrated the entire elementary population in a single school. There is no publicly reported information on disciplinary rates, chronic absenteeism, or staffing ratios, so a parent evaluating school climate or support structures will need to visit and ask. In sum, John F. Kennedy offers a straightforward, single-building elementary experience in a commuter town with a high-cost housing market, serving a diverse student body with academic results that have declined over the past decade.
See more original research from School Decision →