The top reported proficiency rate is 20% in English language arts. The lowest is 13% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Lt Elmer J Mcmahon Elementary
Lt Elmer J McMahon Elementary serves students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Holyoke, an industrial city in western Massachusetts that was once a center of paper manufacturing. The school sits in a residential neighborhood of a city that retains a mix of legacy industrial facilities, specialty manufacturing, and newer research infrastructure such as the Massachusetts Green High Performance Computing Center. Holyoke’s historic downtown, canal system, and nearby Mount Tom Range define the setting, but the city has experienced long-term population decline since its industrial peak and remains economically challenged.
McMahon is a regular public school within the Holyoke Public Schools district, which has been under state receivership for a number of years and continues to be classified as requiring assistance or intervention as of the most recent state accountability data. The district’s funding is overwhelmingly drawn from state sources rather than local property taxes, making it unusually dependent on state education budget decisions. That governance context shapes every aspect of school operations, and families considering the school should be aware that district-level instability has been a persistent condition.
On state assessments administered through the Massachusetts NextGen MCAS, McMahon’s students overall score well below statewide averages in reading, math, and science. The proficiency rate in English language arts has fluctuated over the past several years, reaching its highest point in the 2018-2019 school year and then declining through the pandemic years before recovering somewhat in the most recent testing. Math proficiency has followed a similar pattern, with a notable low point during the 2020-2021 school year. In both subjects, the school’s results place it in the bottom quarter of elementary schools relative to other districts in Hampden County, based on a combined proficiency index across tested subjects and grades. Science proficiency, tested only at grade five, is also low. A parent should look into what academic supports and interventions the school provides to address these results, and how the school’s curriculum aligns with state standards.
The student body is largely Hispanic, with a smaller share of white students and very small percentages of Black, Asian, and multiracial students. Data on the share of students eligible for free or reduced-price meals, as well as the proportion of students with disabilities or who are English learners, was not available in the records reviewed. These are important context for understanding the school’s student supports and resource allocation, so a family may want to ask the school directly about its special education services and English learner programming.
The housing market in Holyoke’s ZIP code area shows home values substantially below the Massachusetts statewide median, and rental costs are moderate relative to local incomes, reflecting the city’s economic profile. The available housing stock includes older mill buildings, traditional single-family homes, and multi-family properties. The neighborhood around the school offers a mix of residential streets and proximity to the downtown core, though Holyoke as a whole has limited walkable amenities outside the canal district and the downtown grid.
As an elementary school serving the earliest grades, McMahon provides the foundational academic experience that feeds into the district’s middle and high schools. The school’s website and any open-house events are the best way for a family to gauge the learning environment day to day, given that the data available here does not cover class sizes, teacher qualifications, or enrichment offerings. The district’s state oversight and the school’s low proficiency scores are realities that warrant careful investigation. For a family committed to being highly engaged in their child’s education and seeking a school with room for growth, McMahon is a neighborhood option that comes with clear challenges and a wider district context that continues to evolve under state intervention.
See more original research from School Decision →