The top reported proficiency rate is 39% in Science. The lowest is 30% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on John T. Nichols Middle
John T. Nichols Middle is the sole public middle school in Middleborough, serving grades six through eight. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and is part of the Middleborough district. The enrollment is substantial for a three-grade middle school, drawing most of its students from the town’s elementary schools. The student body is predominantly white, with small shares of students who are Black, Hispanic, Asian, or identify with two or more races. Data on the share of students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch is not reported, which is a notable gap for parents trying to gauge the school’s economic diversity. Similarly, numbers for students with disabilities and English learners are not available in the data we have; a family may want to ask the school directly about its special education population and supports.
Academic performance on Massachusetts’ NextGen MCAS assessments is a serious concern. In 2024-2025, the share of students scoring at the proficient level or above was modest in reading and math, with science scores somewhat higher and social studies around that same range. Over the past several years, proficiency rates have declined. In 2016-2017, roughly half of students were proficient in English language arts; that figure has since dropped steadily. Math proficiency followed a similar pattern, falling from the high forty percent range to what is now a lower level. When measured against other districts in Plymouth County, Nichols Middle’s overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. The numbers are clear: academic outcomes are weaker than those of many nearby districts, and the trend has been moving downward. The school’s participation rates on the tests were high, so the results reflect nearly the entire student population.
Middleborough itself is a large, spread-out town that mixes rural farmland, cranberry bogs, residential subdivisions, and some light industry. It calls itself the cranberry capital of the world and retains a country character even as development has increased. The main village, Middleborough Center, is walkable and holds town services, but much of the town is car-dependent. Nichols Middle sits on a school campus separate from downtown, as do the other district schools. A new police station and a renovated early childhood center are recent public investments, and the town has seen modest population growth.
Parents considering this school should be aware of major changes ahead for the district. In May 2025, voters approved a debt exclusion to fund a combined middle-high school building project, replacing both Nichols Middle and Middleborough High School with a single facility for grades six through twelve, expected to open in 2029. That project will bring a large tax increase for homeowners over the life of the bond, a lasting financial factor for anyone moving into town. The district also adopted a new elementary literacy curriculum based on the science of reading, implemented in 2023-2024, which will feed into Nichols Middle as those students arrive. A five-year strategic plan (2022-2027) centers on academic excellence, social-emotional learning, equity, and community engagement, and has expanded STEM offerings at the middle school level including robotics and computer science.
In short, Nichols Middle is a school with declining test scores that lag behind county peers, set in a town that is about to undergo a major consolidation of its secondary schools. The district is investing in new facilities and curriculum, but the current academic picture is clearly below the regional midpoint. Families may want to look into how the school supports students who are not yet proficient, what programming for advanced learners looks like, and whether the upcoming construction will affect the school environment during the transition years.
See more original research from School Decision →