The top reported proficiency rate is 37% in Science. The lowest is 35% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Nantucket Elementary
Nantucket Elementary serves children from pre-kindergarten through second grade on the island of Nantucket, a community that is both a town and a county situated roughly thirty miles off the coast of Cape Cod. The school is the entry point for the island’s public school system, and its small grade band means it is fundamentally different from a school that serves older students, a fact that shapes nearly everything about what a parent can expect here.
The school is a regular public school and is not a charter school. It is located on a campus off Surfside Road, south of Nantucket’s downtown core, alongside Cyrus Peirce Middle School and Nantucket High School. This means elementary students attend school on a separated campus rather than in a building integrated with the downtown commercial and civic district, where the town’s library, historic Main Street, and government offices are concentrated.
Because Nantucket Elementary only serves grades PK through two, most of the standard academic performance metrics that apply to older grade levels do not apply here. State testing data from Massachusetts is available only from several years ago, when a cohort of students in grades three through eight took the NextGen MCAS in math and English language arts. Those results come from a time before the current kindergarten through second-grade population was even enrolled in tested grades, so they reflect a different group of students and a different assessment. The data shows that, among the students tested in that older year, just over a third scored proficient or above in math and a similar share in English language arts. Science results for fifth graders from that same year show approximately the same rate. These figures predate the school’s current configuration and testing regime, and any parent considering the school today should understand that they are historical context rather than current classroom outcomes. The district does not have more recent testing data, and because the school does not serve grades where state testing is administered, its academic profile is best understood through other means, such as conversations with the school about early literacy screening, kindergarten readiness, and classroom assessment practices.
The student body is diverse. Hispanic students make up the largest share of enrollment, followed by white students. Black students and students who identify as two or more races also attend in meaningful numbers. Asian students make up a small share, and the school reports no Native American or Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students. The school does not report the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, nor does it report the share of students with individualized education plans or English learner status. A parent who wants to understand the level of economic or linguistic diversity in the building would need to ask the school directly.
The community context is striking. Nantucket’s economy is driven overwhelmingly by tourism, hospitality, and seasonal visitors, and the island’s year-round population of roughly fourteen thousand swells dramatically in summer. Housing prices are among the highest in the country, with the typical home value very far above the national median and well above the Massachusetts state benchmark. More than a third of the island’s land is protected from development, which constrains new construction and reinforces the existing housing shortage. The island has pursued affordable housing initiatives, but the combination of limited land, historic preservation rules, and intense seasonal demand makes housing a central challenge for year-round families. A parent moving to Nantucket for a school placement should be prepared for an extremely tight and expensive housing market.
The island is connected to the mainland by year-round ferry service, including a vehicle ferry, and by air through Nantucket Memorial Airport. The downtown is highly walkable with a historic cobblestone Main Street, but the school campus is a short distance from that core. The year-round community is described as close-knit and self-sufficient, and major year-round employers include the hospital, the public schools, the town and county government, and the Steamship Authority, with tourism and hospitality dominating seasonal employment.
Because Nantucket County contains only one school district, there is no meaningful comparison to other districts within the county. The district brief turned up no major recent changes to report in district leadership, programming, or facilities.
For a parent, the central question this school presents is not whether its test scores are strong or weak, but whether the island’s unique conditions work for your family. The school is small by design and focused on the earliest grades, so the peer environment is one of very young children just beginning school. The absence of current state testing data matters less for this age group than it would for an upper elementary or middle school, because the early grades rely more on developmental screening and teacher evaluation than on standardized assessments. The housing market and seasonal population swings are the more pressing practical concerns. A family that can secure stable year-round housing on the island and values a small, community-anchored elementary school serving a diverse student body in a place with extraordinary natural and historic character may find this a good fit. A family that wants readily comparable test data or a more affordable housing environment will want to look further into these constraints before deciding.
See more original research from School Decision →