The top reported proficiency rate is 38% in Science. The lowest is 31% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on O'donnell Middle School
O'Donnell Middle School serves sixth through eighth grade students in Stoughton, Massachusetts, a suburban town roughly seventeen miles south of Boston. It is a regular public school within the Stoughton district. The school enrolls a sizable student body for a middle school, with each grade level housing several hundred students. The racial and ethnic makeup of the student population is diverse: the largest group is white, followed by a substantial share of Black students, a smaller but still significant Hispanic presence, and smaller Asian and multiracial groups. Data on economic disadvantage, special education, and English learner status was not available, so a full picture of student supports remains incomplete.
Academically, the school’s performance on the state’s Next Generation MCAS assessments places it in the bottom quartile of all districts in Norfolk County when overall proficiency is averaged across tested subjects. In the most recent testing year, roughly one-third of students scored at the proficient level or above in math, English language arts, and eighth-grade social studies, while science proficiency was slightly higher. Participation rates were high, meaning nearly all enrolled students took the tests, so the results reflect the full student body. These figures have declined over the past several years. For both math and ELA, the share of students reaching proficiency was around half a decade ago, fell sharply after the pandemic disruption, and has not recovered. The trajectory is one parents may want to discuss with the school, particularly how the middle school prepares students for the high school academic demands ahead.
The town of Stoughton itself offers a mix of residential neighborhoods, some industrial areas, and protected open spaces like the Bird Street Sanctuary. The historic downtown area around the old train station has a walkable core, but the town is spread out and auto-oriented, served by state routes and an interstate. The commuter rail station that once ran to Boston was permanently closed several years ago, though bus service is available. Housing in the area is expensive relative to national medians, and the market has been competitive, with limited inventory and prices that place homeownership out of reach for many. Rents are also elevated, making the community less accessible to lower-income families. The district recently completed a major new high school building, a project that incurred substantial debt. Annual interest payments on that debt are a meaningful ongoing cost for the district and local taxpayers, something families should factor into long-term financial planning if they are considering buying in Stoughton.
Without data on chronic absenteeism, discipline, staffing ratios, or program offerings like electives or enrichment, it is difficult to assess the full day-to-day experience at O’Donnell. A middle school of this size typically offers some variety in course pathways, but the available information does not detail what is available. Similarly, there is no information on how the school supports students who are below grade level, which may be an important question given the proficiency trends. Families considering the school will want to visit, talk to current parents, and ask about academic interventions, the transition to high school, and how the school addresses the needs of its diverse student body.
In sum, O'Donnell Middle School is a large, diverse public middle school in a suburban town with high housing costs and recent district-level financial commitments. Its state test scores are below the typical level for Norfolk County and have shown a downward trend that predates the pandemic. The school lacks publicly available data on several dimensions that matter to families, making direct inquiry all the more important.
See more original research from School Decision →