The top reported proficiency rate is 48% in Math. The lowest is 44% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Sunderland Elementary
Sunderland Elementary is a public school serving preschool through sixth grade in this small town along the Connecticut River in western Massachusetts. The town itself has shifted from a farming community to a bedroom community, with many residents commuting to jobs at the nearby University of Massachusetts and other area colleges. The school sits in the town center, a low-density residential area with farms and open land, and the built environment gives the town a small New England character. Sunderland has seen its population growth flatten in recent decades, and the housing market reflects that stability with home values near the state median.
The school enrolls students across all elementary grades, with a student body that is predominantly white, with Hispanic and Asian students as the next largest groups. A smaller number of students identify as Black or two or more races. Data on economic disadvantage was not available, nor were counts of students with disabilities or English learners, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about the level of support services and the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals.
On state assessments, Sunderland Elementary’s results place the school’s overall proficiency in the top quartile among districts in Franklin County. That means it performs above the midpoint for the county. Still, the proficiency rates themselves tell a more mixed story. In math, slightly under half of students scored proficient or higher. In English language arts, the share was slightly lower. In science, the rate was similar. These are not strong numbers in absolute terms, and a parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand how the school supports students who are not yet meeting the state bar. The data available for earlier years shows that English language arts proficiency was somewhat higher in the years before the pandemic, dipping afterward and then stabilizing near the current level. Math proficiency followed a similar pattern, with a sharper pandemic-era drop and a partial recovery. The most recent year’s math number is close to where it stood in 2018-19, while English language arts has not fully recovered to that pre-pandemic level. Because the school only serves through sixth grade, there is no graduation rate to consider.
The school does not appear to offer any specialized programs or magnet themes, and no data was available on course access, staffing ratios, or discipline. Given that this is a single-school PK-6 district, the district itself has no separate administrative layer beyond the school, and no recent curriculum changes, property-tax shifts, or other parent-relevant changes surfaced in publicly available information.
The peer environment at Sunderland Elementary is shaped by the town’s size and its relationship to the broader region. After sixth grade, all students must transition to Frontier Regional School in neighboring Deerfield for grades seven through twelve. This means that a family choosing Sunderland Elementary is also choosing a secondary pathway that involves a different school environment and a commute to another town. For a family that values a small, locally rooted elementary school in a quiet town with easy access to the cultural and employment resources of the Amherst area, Sunderland Elementary fits that profile. For a family focused on strong academic outcomes as measured by state tests, the current proficiency rates are a soft spot worth exploring.
See more original research from School Decision →