The top reported proficiency rate is 43% in Math. The lowest is 42% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Sutton Elementary
Sutton Elementary serves grades three through five in the town of Sutton, a rural residential community in Worcester County. The school is one of four buildings in the Sutton public school district, sitting on a campus along Boston Road near Sutton Center alongside the early learning center, middle school, and high school.
The student body is predominantly white, and the enrollment size is typical for an elementary school serving three grade levels. Information on the share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, receive special education services, or are English learners was not available in the data provided. A parent may want to ask the school directly about these figures to get a fuller picture of the student support needs on campus.
On the 2024-25 NextGen MCAS assessments, roughly two out of every five students scored at the proficient level or above in math, English language arts, and science. This places the school’s overall proficiency above the midpoint relative to other districts in Worcester County. The available trend data tells a more complicated story. Proficiency rates in both math and ELA were higher before the pandemic, sitting around the midpoint mark or above in the years leading up to 2019. They dropped noticeably in 2021 and 2022, and have since recovered to a level that is below that earlier peak. The most recent year shows a very slight uptick in ELA after several flat years, while math held steady. A parent looking at these patterns may want to discuss with the school how it is working to bring achievement back to pre-pandemic levels.
Because Sutton Elementary only serves grades three through five, there is no graduation rate to report. There is also no data available on chronic absenteeism or discipline statistics, so the school’s environment in those areas is not captured in this profile.
Sutton itself is a low-density town spread across five villages, with a feel described as rural and focused on family life. The town is predominantly residential, with manufacturing and retail as leading industries. Median household income is high. The housing market reflects the area’s desirability; home values in the ZIP code are above the national benchmark, though somewhat below the statewide figure. The town is car-dependent, with limited walkability concentrated in small village centers, though there are recreational walking trails at Shaw Farm and Purgatory Chasm State Park. Growth has been slow and steady, and the town has participated in state-funded climate preparedness projects, but no large-scale new development was noted in publicly available sources.
The district itself did not have any major recent changes reported in the materials reviewed. This suggests a period of relative stability for families considering the school. For a parent weighing this option, Sutton Elementary offers a solid, mid-range academic foundation in a stable, rural community setting. The proficiency numbers are not exceptional but are competitive within the county, and the dip from pre-pandemic levels is something worth exploring with school leadership. The school serves a largely homogeneous student population in a town that is affluent by national standards, which may be a factor for families seeking a more diverse peer environment.
See more original research from School Decision →