The top reported proficiency rate is 38% in English language arts. The lowest is 29% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Tisbury Elementary
Tisbury Elementary serves students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade in a single building in Vineyard Haven, the main year-round port town on Martha’s Vineyard. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and it feeds into the regional high school, which is not part of this district. Because the school ends at eighth grade, there is no graduation rate to report, and the available academic results come from the state’s MCAS exams in grades three through eight.
The school sits in Vineyard Haven, a village within the town of Tisbury. The village is defined by its working harbor, with Steamship Authority ferries arriving year-round, a walkable Main Street of shops, galleries, and restaurants, and a working waterfront that includes classic wooden shipbuilders. Year-round life centers on the harbor and Main Street corridor, with civic anchors like the public library, Owen Park with its town beach, the Martha’s Vineyard Museum, and the Martha’s Vineyard Playhouse within a short walk of each other. The population swells dramatically in summer, but the year-round community is small. Housing in the area is priced well above national and state benchmarks, and the cost of entry is high. This context is essential for any family considering moving into the district: the school reflects a small island community where the local economy is shaped by tourism, maritime trades, and creative industries, and where housing affordability is a real constraint.
The student body is diverse in its composition. A significant share of students are Hispanic, a notable share are White, and smaller shares identify as Black, two or more races, or American Indian or Alaska Native. The school’s enrollment is small enough that each grade has one or two sections, giving it the feel of a neighborhood school where students move through the grades with the same peers year after year.
State test results show that proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science are below the midpoint of the Dukes County school districts. For English language arts, the share of students scoring proficient or above has declined steadily over roughly the five school years for which trend data is available; this year’s rate is lower than pre-2020 levels. Math performance also shows a decline from earlier years, though it had been more stable in the two years before this most recent testing cycle; the current year’s math proficiency rate is lower than it was the year before. The trend is one parents may want to discuss with the school, particularly in understanding what academic supports are in place and how the school is addressing the trajectory.
Science results are tested in fewer grades, and social studies is assessed only in grade eight. Participation rates across all tested subjects are very high, so the results reflect nearly all enrolled students.
Because this is a single-school district for elementary and middle grades, there are no separate district programs or alternative school options within Tisbury. The district brief did not surface any recent changes with a lasting impact on families. For high school, students attend a regional school shared with other island towns.
For a family considering Tisbury Elementary, the central questions are about fit. The school offers a small, community-grounded experience in a place with a strong sense of place and a walkable village core. The housing market is expensive, and the island’s seasonal economy affects daily life. Academically, the state test results have softened in recent years, and the school’s overall proficiency index is in the bottom quartile among the county’s districts. A parent may want to ask about the school’s current improvement efforts, how it supports students across the range of performance levels, and what the transition to the regional high school looks like for graduates. The school’s size and setting are assets for families who want a close-knit school where teachers know every child; the academic numbers are a starting point for a deeper conversation, not the full picture.
See more original research from School Decision →