The top reported proficiency rate is 83% in English language arts. The lowest is 71% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carroll Manor Elementary
Carroll Manor Elementary is a regular public school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in the unincorporated community of Baldwin, part of Baltimore County Public Schools. It is a school with notably strong academic performance, a very homogenous student body in terms of socioeconomic background, and a setting that feels distinctly rural and residential.
The school's academic results on Maryland's state assessments are a clear strength. In English language arts, proficiency rates across all tested grades are high. In mathematics, the results are also strong, though they show a slight dip from the upper elementary grades to the lower ones. Science results for fifth graders are more moderate. The data covers a single school year, so there is no multi-year trend available to indicate whether performance is improving or declining. For a family focused on strong foundational academics in the elementary years, these numbers are encouraging.
The student population is small for an elementary school serving these grades. A very large majority of the students are white. The share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals is very low, placing the school among the most affluent in the region. This combination of a small, predominantly white, and very affluent student body defines the peer environment. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not reported.
Baldwin itself is a quiet, unincorporated area with no downtown or public transit. It is characterized by large single-family homes on spacious lots, a high rate of telecommuting, and a car-dependent lifestyle. Housing in the area is expensive, well above both the state and national benchmarks, and the housing stock consists predominantly of detached homes. For a family, this means a long car commute is the norm, and the school is a neighborhood anchor within a residential landscape rather than part of a walkable commercial district. The school sits in a stable, low-growth community that maintains a rural character.
Carroll Manor Elementary is part of Baltimore County Public Schools, a large district that is in the midst of several changes. The district has adopted a new elementary literacy curriculum based on the science of reading, which directly affects how reading is taught at this school. A new district-wide cell phone policy restricts phone use during the school day, and boundary changes for several high school feeder systems were approved for the coming school year, though it is not clear if those changes directly affect the Carroll Manor attendance zone. The district is also working to implement the Blueprint for Maryland's Future, a state plan that is increasing funding and expanding pre-K programs. In terms of security, voters recently approved a bond issue for school safety upgrades across the district.
There is no data available on discipline, chronic absenteeism, or course access. The comparison data for Carroll Manor against other schools in Baltimore County was not sufficient to produce a meaningful academic ranking, so its performance is best understood in absolute terms rather than relative to its county peers. The lack of multi-year test data also means there is no way to assess academic momentum here.
This school fits a family seeking a small, strong-performing elementary school in an affluent, rural-suburban setting where academic results are a priority and the community is largely car-dependent. The absence of economic diversity and the high cost of housing in the area shape who is able to attend.
See more original research from School Decision →