The top reported proficiency rate is 61% in English language arts. The lowest is 28% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Northern Middle School
Northern Middle School serves grades six through eight in Accident, a very small rural Appalachian town in Garrett County, far western Maryland. The school is part of Garrett County Public Schools, the county’s only school district, and it operates as a regular public school with no charter or magnet designation. Enrollment is modest for a middle school, and more than half of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, which places it in a context where a substantial share of families have lower household incomes. The student body is almost entirely white, with a small Hispanic presence and a very small number of students identifying as two or more races.
Academically, the picture is uneven. On the Maryland Comprehensive Assessment Program (MCAP), English language arts results are a clear strength: strong majorities of sixth and seventh graders score proficient or above, and the eighth-grade proficiency rate clusters in a similar high range. Science and social studies, tested only in eighth grade, also show a solid middle ground, with about half and a bit under half of students meeting the bar, respectively. Mathematics tells a different story. Sixth-grade math proficiency is low, with a small share of students reaching proficiency; seventh grade improves but still trails the school’s own ELA marks. Eighth-grade math, however, jumps to around half of students proficient, a notable upward shift that suggests either a different curriculum, stronger instruction, or a different cohort. Because this is the only year of data available, it is not possible to tell whether this pattern is typical or reflects a single year. A parent may want to ask the school how math performance changes across grades and what supports exist for students who arrive in sixth grade below grade level.
The school itself sits in Accident, a town that describes itself as a place for raising children and enjoying a reserved country life. The town is extremely small and losing population slightly, with limited commercial activity and no major employer identified in public sources. Residents likely commute to nearby towns for work. Housing values in the area are moderate relative to the state and national benchmarks. The town has a historic house and a volunteer fire department that hosts community events, but no public library or transit system was mentioned in the town’s own materials. For families who value a tight-knit, low-density rural setting, this environment may be appealing, but those accustomed to more amenities or quicker access to services should consider the trade-offs.
Because Garrett County has only one school district, no relative comparison to other districts in the county is possible. The school’s performance can only be understood against state expectations, not against a local peer set. The district itself reported no recent major changes that would affect a family’s decision. Civil rights data, discipline records, course access, and staffing ratios were all absent from the available information, so a parent looking for specifics on school climate or program breadth will need to follow up directly with the school.
Northern Middle School fits families who want a small rural middle school where English and reading achievement are generally solid, who are comfortable with a mostly homogeneous student body, and who understand that math proficiency, especially in the early middle grades, will require attention. The school’s modest enrollment means teachers and staff likely know students well, but the limited public data leaves several practical questions unanswered, particularly around student support services and enrichment opportunities.
See more original research from School Decision →