The top reported proficiency rate is 39% in English language arts. The lowest is 13% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Harpers Choice Middle
Harpers Choice Middle is a regular public school in Columbia, Maryland, serving grades six through eight as part of the Howard County Public Schools system. Columbia is a large planned community of ten self-contained villages, designed with an extensive network of pathways and village centers, situated between Baltimore and Washington, D.C. The community as a whole is highly educated and affluent, but the school’s own student body is more economically diverse, with roughly half of its students qualifying for free or reduced-price meals. The student population is predominantly Black and Hispanic, with smaller shares of White, Asian, and multiracial students.
Academically, the picture is mixed. In English language arts, the share of students scoring proficient or above is around two-fifths, with sixth grade at that level, seventh grade in a range that sits near half, and eighth grade a bit lower. These are middling results for a state that sets a fairly high proficiency bar. In math, the pattern is more concerning. Proficiency declines sharply across grade levels, from about a quarter of sixth graders to a very small share of seventh and eighth graders. The overall math proficiency across the school is low. A parent considering the school will want to ask what math support and interventions are in place, particularly for students who are already behind when they enter sixth grade.
On the other hand, a small group of students takes advanced coursework in algebra and geometry, and those students perform well, with strong proficiency rates. This suggests that the school offers a pathway for students who are ready for accelerated math, but the vast majority of students are not on that track. In eighth grade science and social studies, proficiency rates are in the range of a quarter to a third, again indicating that many students are not meeting the state standard.
There is only a single year of state assessment data available, so it is not possible to see whether these results represent a trend or a snapshot. The school’s parent district, Howard County Public Schools, recently opened a new high school and has adopted a strategic plan that explicitly targets middle school math proficiency and reading by grade three. That district-level attention may eventually benefit Harpers Choice Middle, but for now the math numbers are a soft spot that families should investigate directly by visiting the school and asking about curriculum, tutoring, and differentiated instruction.
Columbia’s housing market is expensive relative to national averages, and the area has seen ongoing redevelopment in its downtown core. The district has experienced teacher salary increases that have grown the operating budget, which may affect local property taxes. The school itself is located in one of Columbia’s villages, and students likely walk or bike via the community’s pathway system. Because the school does not serve high school grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and the civil rights data on discipline, special education, and English learner services was not available in the provided information.
Overall, Harpers Choice Middle serves a diverse student body against the backdrop of a wealthy county, and its academic results reveal a sharp divide between a small group of students taking advanced courses and a larger group struggling with math in particular. Families with strong math support at home, or whose children are already on an accelerated track, may find the advanced offerings appealing. For those whose children need extra help, the school’s capacity to close gaps is an open question worth pursuing.
See more original research from School Decision →