The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in English language arts. The lowest is 23% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Deer Isle-stonington High Sch
Deer Isle-Stonington High School sits on an island in Hancock County, Maine, reachable by a suspension bridge over Eggemoggin Reach. It is the secondary school for the Deer Isle-Stonington Community School District, which also operates an elementary school in town. The campus sits near the village center along Church Street, close to the municipal building, the library, and the town office. This is a small school serving grades nine through twelve. The student body is almost entirely white, and a substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch.
The surrounding community is rural and car-dependent, with no public transit. Deer Isle spreads across nine villages, and civic life centers on the main village area rather than a separated campus. The local economy blends lobstering, granite quarrying, arts and crafts studios, and tourism businesses such as inns, campgrounds, restaurants, and shops. The Haystack Mountain School of Crafts is a publicly reported landmark on the island. No large employers with named employee counts appear in available sources. The economy runs on independent operators in fishing, quarrying, art, and hospitality, along with municipal and school district employment. Housing here carries a price-to-income burden above the national comparison, and the vacancy rate is high, consistent with substantial seasonal and second-home ownership. Property valuations have climbed steeply in recent years, and the town adopted a comprehensive plan addressing these dynamics.
State assessment results are available for the most recent reported year, though they come with caveats. The data is labeled as grades three through eight, which does not align with this school's grade band of nine through twelve, and the tested group is small. Among those tested, English language arts proficiency reached above the halfway mark, while math proficiency fell below a third and science proficiency landed below a quarter. Average scale scores were missing, and participation rates were suppressed. Because the tested count is small and the grade-level labeling does not match the school's actual grade band, a parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand what these results reflect. No multi-year trend data was available, and the assessment itself underwent a name and cut-score change, making year-over-year comparison unreliable.
Several data categories were absent. No graduation rate was provided. Civil rights data, including discipline and course access information, was not available. Staffing, attendance, and Title I status were missing. Program offerings such as Advanced Placement, dual-credit, or career pathways were not reported. Information on special populations, including students with individualized education programs and English learners, was missing. The school is not a charter or magnet, and its governance sits within the community school district, whose board has five members serving three-year terms.
What the available picture shows is a very small, rural island high school in a community where the year-round population is aging and seasonal housing dominates the real estate market. The school serves a nearly homogeneous student body with a high level of economic need. Academic results are mixed, with English language arts the relative bright spot and math and science both areas where proficiency is low. A family considering this school would be looking at a close-knit island setting where the school functions as a central community institution, but where program breadth, specialized offerings, and academic outcomes may be limited by the constraints of scale and geography. The gaps in available data mean a parent would need to contact the school directly for a fuller picture of graduation outcomes, course offerings, and student support services.
See more original research from School Decision →