Original Research by School Decision on Pleasant Hill School
Pleasant Hill School is one of three primary schools serving kindergarten through second grade in Scarborough Public Schools, a coastal southern Maine district just south of Portland. The school sits on Highland Avenue in the Pleasant Hill neighborhood, one of thirteen distinct areas that make up this sprawling town. Because Pleasant Hill serves only the earliest grades, there are no state assessment results to report. Maine does not test students in kindergarten, first, or second grade, so the absence of proficiency data reflects the grade band, not a gap in performance. There is also no graduation rate for the same reason. What the data does tell a parent is about enrollment, peer composition, and the community surrounding the school.
The school is small, as one would expect for a building serving three early grades. Its student body is predominantly white, with small numbers of Asian, Black, Hispanic, and multiracial students. Economic disadvantage is low here. Only a sliver of families qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is consistent with Scarborough's broader housing market and household income levels. The school does not report IEP or English-learner figures, so a parent wanting to understand special-education services or language support would need to ask the school directly. No staffing, attendance, discipline, or course-access data was available either, so those dimensions of school life are left out here rather than guessed at.
Scarborough itself shapes much of what Pleasant Hill is. The town is one of the fastest-growing communities in Maine, a largely residential suburb spanning more than fifty square miles with no single traditional downtown. Instead, civic life is distributed across those thirteen neighborhoods, and the school district mirrors that pattern. The three K-2 primary schools, including Pleasant Hill, are spread across different parts of town rather than clustered on the central campus where the middle school and high school sit. Wentworth School, which picks up at third grade, serves as the next step after all three primaries. This distributed model means young children attend school close to home in their early years before consolidating.
Housing in Scarborough is expensive relative to both state and national benchmarks. Typical home values run well above the statewide figure, and rents are similarly elevated. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home exceeds what rent would cost by a meaningful margin, and both consume a large share of median household income. For families considering a move into the Pleasant Hill catchment, the housing market is a real factor. The town's growth has brought commercial development along Route One, with large retailers and the Hannaford supermarket headquarters providing local employment, but many residents also commute the short distance into Portland. The town is car-dependent by design, crossed by Interstates 95 and 295, U.S. Route 1, and several state routes.
The district is in the midst of a major school building project, publicly reported on the Scarborough Public Schools website. This capital investment points to a community putting resources into its facilities, which could affect the learning environment across the district in coming years. A parent might want to look into how that project touches the primary schools, or whether enrollment growth in Scarborough is driving the construction.
Natural amenities give the town much of its identity. Scarborough Marsh, the largest contiguous tidal marsh in Maine, draws kayakers and birders. Four beaches line the coast, and the Scarborough Land Trust preserves open space. These are the surroundings families at Pleasant Hill live in: a coastal suburban community with strong recreational assets, an auto-oriented layout, rising housing costs, and a district investing in its buildings. The school itself is a small, early-grades neighborhood primary serving a relatively advantaged student population in a town that continues to grow.
See more original research from School Decision →