The top reported proficiency rate is 29% in English language arts. The lowest is 13% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Marvin L Winans Academy Middle School
Marvin L Winans Academy Middle School was a charter school in Detroit, operating under the Marvin L. Winans Academy of Performing Arts district. The school served middle school grades and was located on McKinney Street on the city's east side, in the 48224 zip code. The school is now closed, which is the most important fact for any family encountering this profile. A parent looking at this entry is reading about a school that is no longer enrolling students.
The academic record that exists comes from the 2022-23 school year, the last full assessment cycle reflected in the data. State testing results were available across math, English language arts, science, and social studies for grades six through eight. These results paint a picture of a school where most students were not reaching proficiency on Michigan's M-STEP and PSAT assessments. In math, the sixth and eighth grades showed proficiency in the lowest reported range, with no students clearing the proficient threshold. Seventh-grade math proficiency was modest. English language arts followed a similar pattern, with sixth grade in the lowest range, seventh grade showing a somewhat higher share of proficient students, and eighth grade reaching a higher level still, with roughly a third of tested students proficient on the PSAT. Science and social studies results for eighth grade were low, with science proficiency in a narrow band and social studies in the lowest reported range.
The tested cohorts were small, which means a few students moving above or below the proficiency line could shift the picture meaningfully from year to year. No trend data was available to show whether these results were improving, declining, or stable over time. Participation rates were also missing from the data set, so it is not possible to say how completely the student body was represented in these results.
Enrollment and demographic data were not available. The data set does not include total enrollment, free-or-reduced-price lunch counts, racial or ethnic breakdowns, special education rates, or English learner figures. Because the school is closed, these gaps may reflect the fact that current reporting systems no longer carry active records for this campus. A parent would not be able to assess the peer environment or student support profile from what remains.
No graduation rate applies here, since this was a middle school serving grades that do not culminate in a high school diploma. The same is true of advanced coursework, career pathways, and dual-credit offerings: none were reported, and for a middle school these programs would typically not apply.
The surrounding housing market in the school's zip code is among the more affordable in Michigan. Home values sit well below the state and national benchmarks, and the area has seen a modest year-over-year decline in home prices. Rents are also below the state level, with a slight year-over-year increase. For families who were zoned to or considering this school, the housing context was one of low-cost entry points into homeownership, in a part of Detroit that has experienced long-term disinvestment alongside the broader citywide revitalization.
Detroit itself is a major urban center with a mix of commercial, industrial, and residential uses. The city is the historic heart of the American automotive industry, with the Big Three automakers maintaining major operations in and around the metro area. Revitalization efforts since the 2000s have brought restored theaters, new sports stadiums, riverfront redevelopment, and residential construction concentrated in Midtown, Corktown, and along the East Riverfront. The city's population has recently grown for two consecutive years, driven by immigration and new housing development. Walkability varies by neighborhood, with downtown and Midtown more pedestrian-friendly than outer areas. The school's location on the east side would have placed it in a more car-dependent residential zone.
The district brief for Marvin L. Winans Academy of Performing Arts returned no parent-relevant changes, such as curriculum shifts, facility investments, or governance actions. This is consistent with the school's closed status.
For a parent encountering this profile, the practical takeaway is straightforward. This school is no longer operating. The last available test results showed mostly low proficiency levels across subjects and grades, though eighth-grade English language arts stood out as the strongest result. Without enrollment, demographic, or program data, there is little to characterize the school's environment or offerings beyond what the assessment record shows. Families looking for a middle school in this part of Detroit would need to look at currently operating schools in the area.
See more original research from School Decision →