The top reported proficiency rate is 16% in English language arts. The lowest is 10% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carstens Elementarymiddle School
Carstens Elementary-Middle School sits on Essex Avenue on Detroit's east side, serving pre-kindergarten through eighth grade as part of Detroit Public Schools Community District. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and its enrollment is small for a building spanning that many grades. Nearly every student qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body is almost entirely Black. The school does not report data on English learners or students with individualized education programs, so those pieces of the picture are absent here.
On state assessments, Carstens struggles. Math proficiency is very low across every tested grade, with third grade showing the highest rate and upper grades falling into the lowest reporting band. English language arts fares slightly better but still lands in the low range, with sixth, seventh, and eighth grades reaching proficiency at modest levels. Science and social studies results, where reported, also sit in the lowest band. When measured against other schools and districts in Wayne County, Carstens lands in the bottom quartile for overall proficiency. A parent considering this school may want to ask leadership directly what academic interventions and supports are in place, and how the school plans to move results forward.
The school does not have a graduation rate, which is expected because it serves only elementary and middle grades. Chronic absenteeism and attendance data were not available, nor were discipline, course access, or staffing details. Title I status was also not reported, though given the free-or-reduced-price-lunch rate, the school almost certainly receives Title I funding. Programs data was not provided, so there is no information here about extracurriculars, after-school offerings, or specialized academic tracks. These gaps mean the portrait is incomplete, and a family would want to fill them in through direct conversation with the school.
The surrounding neighborhood is part of a city whose story most readers will know in broad strokes. Detroit is a major urban center, historically anchored by the American automotive industry, with General Motors downtown and Ford and Stellantis in surrounding suburbs. The city has experienced decades of population decline and disinvestment following industrial restructuring, but recent years have brought renewed growth. Publicly reported census data shows Detroit's population increasing for consecutive years, driven partly by immigration and new housing development. Revitalization has been concentrated in Midtown, Corktown, and the East Riverfront, with projects like the Hudson's site redevelopment and the Gordie Howe International Bridge underway. The Detroit Riverwalk, Belle Isle, and the Detroit Institute of Arts serve as civic anchors, and the QLine streetcar and People Mover connect parts of the downtown core.
For families thinking about housing, the zip code around Carstens is very affordable compared to state and national benchmarks. Wayne County's median listing price sits well below the state median, and home values in the school's immediate area are lower still. The county market shows ample active listings and modest year-over-year price movement, with homes spending roughly a month and a half on the market. Rental data for the immediate area was not available. This is a low-cost housing environment, which can be attractive for families looking to buy, though it also reflects the economic pressures the community has faced.
At the district level, Detroit Public Schools Community District has announced a multi-year facilities improvement plan to renovate and modernize school buildings, funded through capital projects and grants. Publicly reported district financial documents reference ongoing annual investments into a Capital Projects fund to address facility issues. For a family at Carstens, this could mean building improvements on the horizon, though it may also bring disruption during construction.
What this means in practice is that Carstens is a small, community-based school in an affordable Detroit neighborhood, serving a student population that faces concentrated economic need. Its academic results are low, and the data available does not paint a picture of strong outcomes or rich program offerings. A family whose priority is strong test scores or broad extracurricular options would likely look elsewhere or push hard for more information. A family tied to the neighborhood, or one focused on finding a close-to-home option with room to grow, would want to visit, meet the principal, and ask pointed questions about academic supports, attendance, and what the district's facilities plan means for this building specifically.
See more original research from School Decision →