The top reported proficiency rate is 14% in Math. The lowest is 8% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Gardner Elementary School
Gardner Elementary School sits on Mansfield Street in Detroit's 48228 zip code, serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as a regular public school in the Detroit Public Schools Community District. It is a neighborhood elementary school of modest size, drawing from a surrounding community where housing is among the most affordable in the region. The school's enrollment is predominantly Black, with a substantial White minority and a smaller Hispanic presence. A very large share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic conditions of the area.
On state assessments, Gardner's results are low across every tested grade and subject. Third-grade math and English language arts proficiency rates are in the single digits, and fourth-grade math proficiency falls at the bottom of the reported range. Fifth grade shows the strongest results, with roughly one in five students reaching proficiency in both math and English language arts, though science and social studies proficiency at that grade remain in the single digits. When compared to schools across Wayne County districts, Gardner's overall proficiency places it in the bottom quartile. A parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand what academic supports and interventions are in place.
The school does not have graduation rate data, which is expected because it serves only elementary grades. Data on chronic absenteeism, staffing ratios, discipline, course access, and Title I status was either missing or not reported in the available sources, so those dimensions of the school environment could not be assessed here. Information on special education and English learner populations was also not available.
Detroit itself is a major urban center with a deep industrial and cultural identity. Publicly reported sources describe it as the historic heart of the American automotive industry, with General Motors, Ford, and Stellantis all maintaining major operations in the metro area. The city has experienced decades of population decline and disinvestment but has seen recent revitalization, including restoration of historic theaters, new sports venues, riverfront redevelopment, and residential construction concentrated in Midtown, Corktown, and the East Riverfront. Publicly reported census estimates indicate Detroit's population grew for two consecutive years through 2025, the first time since the 1950s that the city led Michigan in population growth. Walkability varies sharply by neighborhood, with downtown and Midtown more pedestrian-friendly and outer areas more car-dependent. Gardner's location on the city's west side places it in one of the more residential, working-class sections of Detroit.
The housing market around the school reflects the broader economic context of this part of the city. Home values in the zip code are far below state and national benchmarks, and rents are similarly modest. The Wayne County housing market as a whole has seen an increase in active listings recently, with median listing prices well below the state average. For families considering the area, this translates into relatively accessible housing costs, though the economic challenges that accompany deeply affordable housing markets are also part of the picture.
At the district level, Detroit Public Schools Community District has announced a multi-year facilities improvement plan aimed at renovating and modernizing school buildings, funded through capital projects funding and grants. Publicly reported district financial documents reference ongoing annual investments into a capital projects fund to address facility conditions. For Gardner families, this could mean building improvements in coming years, though it may also involve temporary disruptions during renovation work.
What Gardner offers is a small neighborhood elementary setting within a large urban district, in a community where housing costs are low and the city is undergoing visible if uneven revitalization. The academic data points to real challenges in proficiency, and families would benefit from asking the school directly about its instructional strategies, intervention programs, and any supports available for students working below grade level.
See more original research from School Decision →