The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Science. The lowest is 46% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Old Mission Peninsula School
Old Mission Peninsula School is a small charter school serving kindergarten through sixth grade on Traverse City's Old Mission Peninsula. With a total enrollment of roughly 135 students spread across seven grade levels, the school offers an intimate setting where class sizes at each tested grade are in the low-to-mid twenties. The student body is predominantly white, with a smaller Hispanic enrollment and a handful of students identified as two or more races. About a quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a relatively modest share. The school does not currently report IEP or English-learner counts, so families needing special-education or language-support services should ask the school directly about what is available. Sixth grade shows no enrolled students this year, which a parent may want to clarify with the school, as it could reflect a phased grade rollout or a transitional year.
On state assessments, the school's results tell a mixed but generally encouraging story. English language arts proficiency is a clear strength, with well over half of third, fourth, and fifth graders scoring proficient or above, and fourth grade reaching a particularly high mark. Science and social studies proficiency among fifth graders also sit comfortably above the majority threshold. Mathematics is more uneven. Third-grade math proficiency is strong, but it drops noticeably by fourth grade and falls further in fifth grade, where fewer than a third of tested students reached proficiency. The tested cohorts are small, so a few students moving in or out of the proficient range can shift results meaningfully, but the downward trajectory across grades is something a parent may want to discuss with the school, particularly how math instruction is sequenced and supported in the upper elementary years.
Measured against other districts in Grand Traverse County, the school's overall proficiency index lands in the top quartile, the highest among the county's eight districts for which data was available. That positioning reflects the strength of ELA, science, and social studies more than math. Because the school serves only elementary and early middle grades, no graduation rate or chronic absenteeism figure is reported; those measures do not apply to this grade band.
The school sits in Traverse City, a small but regionally dominant community on Grand Traverse Bay. Publicly reported sources describe a city anchored by tourism, cherry production and processing, a growing wine industry, and healthcare, with Munson Medical Center serving as a major regional employer. The Boardman River runs through downtown to the bay, and the compact core has shops, restaurants, and civic venues such as the City Opera House. The surrounding townships, including Peninsula Township where the school is located, are primarily suburban and residential. Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore sits roughly twenty miles to the west-northwest. The National Cherry Festival brings a large seasonal influx of visitors each summer. The local economy has been diversifying toward wine tourism, technology through the 20Fathoms incubator, and healthcare expansion, while nearby Garfield Township has grown as a bedroom community.
Housing in the school's zip code carries a typical home value well above the Michigan state benchmark, and rents are correspondingly elevated. This places the area on the costlier side of the state's housing market, which a family weighing relocation should factor in. The district brief turned up no major parent-relevant changes in recent operations; available sources describe steady functioning since the school's opening.
In sum, Old Mission Peninsula School offers a small, community-rooted charter option with solid reading, science, and social-studies outcomes and a peer environment shaped by modest class sizes. Math in the upper elementary grades is the soft spot parents should probe. The setting, on a scenic peninsula near a vibrant small city, carries a higher housing cost that pairs with the region's outdoor recreation, cultural events, and tourism-driven economy.
See more original research from School Decision →