Original Research by School Decision on New Options High School
New Options High School is an alternative public high school in Allendale, Michigan, serving grades nine through twelve as part of Allendale Public Schools. It is a very small school even for an alternative program, with most of its students concentrated in the upper grades. No ninth graders are enrolled, and the student body skews toward juniors and seniors, which fits the profile of a school designed to catch students who need a different path after a difficult start elsewhere.
The school sits in a township shaped by a single dominant institution. Allendale Charter Township is home to the main campus of Grand Valley State University, and the university's presence touches nearly everything about the place, from employment to housing to the age of the population. The township publicly describes itself as maintaining a family-friendly, rural character even as it ranks among the fastest-growing in the region. There is no incorporated municipality and no traditional downtown. Civic and commercial life clusters around the GVSU campus and the township offices near Allendale Community Park. Development spreads across a large geographic area, and the township is automobile-dependent, with M-45 and I-96 as the primary commuter routes connecting it to Grand Rapids and the Lake Michigan shore. A regional bus system, The Rapid, links Allendale and GVSU to Grand Rapids.
For families thinking about where they would live, the housing market here runs well above the state benchmark and somewhat above the national one. The area has seen steady year-over-year home value appreciation, and with current mortgage rates, the estimated monthly cost of ownership is substantial. A large volume of off-campus student housing also shapes the rental market, a byproduct of GVSU's continued expansion. The township has grown quickly over the past decade, and Allendale Public Schools has responded by adding dedicated early-childhood infrastructure, though available sources do not point to other recent program-level changes at the secondary level.
Back at New Options itself, a substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly white, with a meaningful Hispanic presence and a small fraction of students identifying as two or more races. Data on special education and English learner populations was not reported, so those profiles remain unknown.
State assessment results were not available for this school. The comparison set, which positions the school relative to districts in Ottawa County, could not produce proficiency, graduation, or chronic absenteeism metrics because the entity-level values are missing. This is common for alternative schools, which often sit outside standard accountability reporting or serve a population that does not test in the usual way. A parent should not read the absence of those numbers as evidence of poor performance. It does mean, though, that the usual academic benchmarks a family might use to compare schools are simply not on the page here.
What remains is a qualitative picture. New Options is a small, late-intervention alternative school in a growing, university-anchored township with a tight housing market and limited transit outside the campus corridor. The school appears designed for students who need a different environment to finish their high school education, and the grade distribution supports that read. A parent considering this school would want to ask the district directly about the academic pathway it offers, how students transition in and out, and what supports sit underneath the small enrollment. Those are the questions the available data cannot answer.
See more original research from School Decision →