The top reported proficiency rate is 41% in English language arts. The lowest is 24% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Mcalearsawden Elem School
McAlear-Sawden Elementary sits on Midland Road in Bay City, part of the Bay City School District. It is a regular public school serving pre-kindergarten through fifth grade, with an enrollment that makes it a mid-sized building for its grade band. The student body is predominantly white, with smaller Hispanic and multiracial populations and a handful of students from other racial backgrounds. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the working-class character of much of the surrounding area.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessments for the most recent school year, the school's results land in a mixed range. English language arts is the stronger area, with roughly two-fifths of third, fourth, and fifth graders reaching proficiency, the fifth-grade rate being the highest of the three. Math tells a more uneven story. Third grade performed respectably, but fourth and fifth grade proficiency dropped off, with roughly a quarter of students meeting the bar in each. Fifth-grade science landed in between, and fifth-grade social studies was the weakest result, with under a quarter of tested students proficient. When the school's overall proficiency is measured against the Bay County district cohort, McAlear-Sawden sits below the midpoint, though not at the bottom of the range. A parent looking at these numbers may want to ask the school what supports are in place for math instruction in the upper elementary grades, where the dip is most visible.
Because this is an elementary school, there is no graduation rate to report, and no chronic absenteeism figure was available in the data provided. Special population data, including individualized education program counts and English learner counts, were also missing, so those pieces of the picture are not included here.
Bay City itself is the county seat of Bay County, positioned along the Saginaw River just upriver from Saginaw Bay on Lake Huron. It grew out of a nineteenth-century lumber boom, and the Victorian mansions from that era still line streets like Center Avenue, now registered as historic landmarks. When the pine forests were depleted, the economy shifted to soft-coal mining, commercial fishing, and beet-sugar refining. Today the employment base spans healthcare, public sector work, and diversified manufacturing, including auto equipment, plastics, cement, and shipbuilding. McLaren Bay Region is the largest employer, with the school district itself ranking among the top. Michigan Sugar is also based here.
The city is divided by the Saginaw River into east and west sides, connected by four bascule bridges. Downtown runs along the riverfront, anchored by Wenonah Park on the east bank and the larger Veterans Memorial Park on the west, where many of the city's summer festivals take place. River Roar, St. Stan's Polish Festival, the Bay City Fireworks Festival, and the River of Time living history reenactment draw crowds seasonally. Cultural institutions include the State Theatre, the Bay County Historical Museum, Studio 23, and the Delta College Planetarium. Street life concentrates downtown and along the river during festival season, while the broader built environment ranges from residential neighborhoods to commercial strips and industrial pockets.
Bay City's population has been in steady decline, a pattern common to many Michigan industrial cities. A publicly reported point of friction in recent years has been the city's lease of two of its bridges, Independence and Liberty, to a private operator. Liberty Bridge reopened with tolling in 2023, and residents have voiced concerns about transparency and the cost of crossing. For a family considering the area, the bridge situation is a practical matter if commuting across the river is part of the daily routine.
Housing in the school's zip code is affordable by both state and national standards. Home values sit well below the Michigan benchmark and far below the national one, and rents are similarly modest. The price-to-income ratio is low, and the gap between a typical monthly mortgage payment and rent is narrow, which means the rent-versus-own decision may come down to personal preference and job stability rather than pure cost pressure. No data on program offerings, staffing ratios, discipline, or attendance was available, so those dimensions of the school environment are left out here rather than guessed at.
McAlear-Sawden is a conventional neighborhood elementary in a riverfront city with deep industrial roots, affordable housing, and an active seasonal civic life. Its ELA results are the steadiest part of its academic profile, while math in the upper grades is the area a parent would most want to understand better before enrolling.
See more original research from School Decision →