The top reported proficiency rate is 42% in Science. The lowest is 22% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Schall Elementary School
Schall Elementary School sits in Caro, the county seat of Tuscola County in Michigan's Upper Thumb. The school serves third through fifth graders as part of Caro Community Schools, the local public district. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and it draws from a community where agriculture and agricultural processing define the working landscape.
Caro itself is a small city with a traditional downtown along the M-81 corridor. Storefronts, a historic theater, restaurants, and the Tuscola County Courthouse give the commercial core its identity. The surrounding region is rich farmland, and the city's industrial base centers on a Michigan Sugar processing facility jointly owned by local sugarbeet farmers and a POET Biorefining corn ethanol plant. A state-operated psychiatric hospital, county government, and a critical access hospital round out the major employers. Community life includes more than ten parks, a splash pad, an 18-hole golf course, the Tuscola County fairgrounds, and the Cass River running nearby. Signature events such as the Pumpkin Festival, Farmers Market, Gingerbread Fest, and Cars and Crafts bring seasonal street life. No public transit system was found in publicly reported sources, and no specific walkability data was available.
Housing in the school's zip code is affordable relative to state and national benchmarks. Typical home values sit well below both the Michigan and national medians, and the price-to-income ratio is modest. Home values have been appreciating at a healthy clip recently. This is a market where a family can buy in at a lower price point than most of the state, though rental data was not available.
At Schall, the student body is small for a three-grade school. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic profile of the community. The enrollment is predominantly white, with a smaller Hispanic presence and very few students from other racial or ethnic backgrounds. Data on students with individualized education programs and English learners was not reported, so those figures are absent here rather than implied to be low.
State assessment results come from the M-STEP, the standard Michigan test, and cover the most recent school year. In math, proficiency rates across the three grades land in a similar range, with fifth grade dipping below the third and fourth. English language arts follows a pattern where fourth grade is the weakest, with third and fifth grade somewhat higher. Fifth-grade science stands out as the strongest result, with a share of students meeting proficiency that exceeds any other subject at the school. Fifth-grade social studies is the lowest result across all tested subjects and grades. When the school's overall proficiency is compared against districts in Tuscola County, Schall sits below the midpoint, with the district median above it and the top-performing district well above. The lowest-performing district in the county sits just below Schall's level. No multi-year trend data was available, so it is not possible to say whether these results are improving, declining, or holding steady. Participation rates were also not reported.
Because Schall is an elementary school serving only grades three through five, there is no graduation rate, and the school does not offer AP courses, career pathways, or dual-credit programs. Those questions belong to the secondary level. No data on chronic absenteeism, discipline, staffing ratios, course access, or Title I status was available for this school. The district brief for Caro Community Schools was searched for recent parent-relevant changes, but little of lasting impact was found, so there is nothing to report on that front.
What the picture does show is a small-town elementary school in an affordable, agriculturally rooted community, with state test results that are below the midpoint for the county. Science is a relative bright spot. Social studies and fourth-grade English language arts are the soft spots. A parent weighing this school may want to look into the specific supports the school offers for literacy and math, how it serves students from lower-income households, and what interventions are in place for the grade levels and subjects where proficiency is lowest. Asking the school directly about participation rates and trend data would also help fill in what the public reports do not capture.
See more original research from School Decision →