The top reported proficiency rate is 43% in English language arts. The lowest is 20% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Engadine Schools
Engadine Schools is a single-campus public school serving pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade in one of Michigan's most rural corners. The campus sits along Melville Street in the unincorporated community of Engadine, within Garfield Township in Mackinac County, and the district covers a vast geographic area ranking among the largest in the state by land even as its enrollment stays small. For a parent weighing this school, the first thing to understand is that it functions as the community's central institution in a place where there is almost nothing else: no downtown, no sidewalks, no transit, and only a handful of commercial enterprises. The school campus doubles as a community gathering space, and publicly reported sources describe school facilities being used for community events.
The student body is small, with roughly two dozen students per grade in the upper years and smaller cohorts in the elementary grades. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The racial and ethnic composition is predominantly white, with a meaningful American Indian or Alaska Native presence and a smaller share of students identifying as two or more races. IEP and English learner data were not reported, so those populations cannot be characterized here.
On state assessments, the picture is mixed and tilts soft, particularly in mathematics. Grade three results were suppressed because no students were tested in that grade, and grade six proficiency in both math and ELA was reported only as a range rather than a precise figure, which often reflects small cohort sizes in rural schools. Where precise results were reported, math proficiency was low across grades four through eight, with the weakest showing in eighth grade. ELA results were somewhat stronger, with fourth and eighth grade landing in a middling band, though grade seven ELA was reported as a range that suggests a low result. Science and social studies followed a similar pattern, with fifth grade performing better than eighth grade in both subjects. Against the comparison set of districts in Mackinac County, Engadine's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades sits in the bottom quartile. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, particularly around math instruction in the middle grades.
Graduation rate data was not available for this school. Chronic absenteeism data was also missing. Neither gap is explained by the grade band, since the school does serve high school grades; the absence appears to reflect what was reported rather than what was tested. Program offerings such as AP courses, career pathways, or dual-credit options were not provided, so nothing can be said about them one way or the other. Staffing data was absent as well.
The housing market around Engadine is affordable relative to both state and national benchmarks. Typical home values sit well below the Michigan median, and the price-to-income ratio is modest. Recent year-over-year appreciation has been strong, suggesting the area is catching up from a low base rather than entering a boom. A sizable share of housing units in the ZIP code area appear to be seasonal or vacation properties, which shapes the community's character: quiet, forested, and sparsely populated. The Hiawatha Sportsman's Club, a large private recreational club headquartered in Engadine, owns extensive landholdings that constrain development. No major new housing projects or planned development were identified.
The broader Upper Peninsula pattern of stable or slowly declining population applies here. The community has no growth trajectory to speak of. Canadian National Railway runs an active freight line through the area but no longer stops. U.S. Route 2 was rerouted south of Engadine decades ago, bypassing the community from through traffic. What remains is a settlement stretched along two intersecting highways, with the school as its anchor.
For a family already drawn to rural Upper Peninsula life, hunting and fishing, snowmobile trails, and proximity to Lake Superior State Forest and Lake Michigan shoreline, Engadine Schools offers a small, consolidated pathway from preschool through senior year in one building. The academic results are a real consideration, especially in math, and the lack of reported program data makes it hard to know what enrichment or advanced options exist. A parent considering this school would benefit from asking the administration directly about middle-grade math support, high school course offerings, and graduation outcomes.
See more original research from School Decision →